Collingridge Moore Danni, Garner Alex, Cotterell Natalie, Harding Andrew J E, Preston Nancy
Division of Health Research, Lancaster University, Lancaster, UK.
Lancaster Medical School, Lancaster University, Lancaster, UK.
BMC Geriatr. 2024 May 3;24(1):394. doi: 10.1186/s12877-024-04867-9.
The disproportionate effect of COVID-19 on long term care facility (LTCF) residents has highlighted the need for clear, consistent guidance on the management of pandemics in such settings. As research exploring the experiences of LTCFs during the pandemic and the implications of mass hospital discharge, restricting staff movement, and limiting visitation from relatives are emerging, an in-depth review of policies, guidance and recommendations issued during this time could facilitate wider understanding in this area.
To identify policies, guidance, and recommendations related to LTCF staff and residents, in England issued by the government during the COVID-19 pandemic, developing a timeline of key events and synthesizing the policy aims, recommendations, implementation and intended outcomes.
A scoping review of publicly available policy documents, guidance, and recommendations related to COVID-19 in LTCFs in England, identified using systematic searches of UK government websites. The main aims, recommendations, implementation and intended outcomes reported in included documents were extracted. Data was analysed using thematic synthesis following a three-stage approach: coding the text, grouping codes into descriptive themes, and development of analytical themes.
Thirty-three key policy documents were included in the review. Six areas of recommendations were identified: infection prevention and control, hospital discharge, testing and vaccination, staffing, visitation and continuing routine care. Seven areas of implementation were identified: funding, collaborative working, monitoring and data collection, reducing workload, decision making and leadership, training and technology, and communication.
LTCFs remain complex settings, and it is imperative that lessons are learned from the experiences during COVID-19 to ensure that future pandemics are managed appropriately. This review has synthesized the policies issued during this time, however, the extent to which such guidance was communicated to LTCFs, and subsequently implemented, in addition to being effective, requires further research. In particular, understanding the secondary effects of such policies and how they can be introduced within the existing challenges inherent to adult social care, need addressing.
新冠病毒病(COVID-19)对长期护理机构(LTCF)居民产生的不成比例影响凸显了在此类场所进行疫情管理时需要清晰、一致的指导。随着探索长期护理机构在疫情期间的经历以及大规模医院出院、限制工作人员流动和限制亲属探视的影响的研究不断涌现,对这一时期发布的政策、指导意见和建议进行深入审查有助于更广泛地理解该领域情况。
确定英国政府在COVID-19大流行期间发布的与长期护理机构工作人员和居民相关的政策、指导意见和建议,制定关键事件时间表,并综合政策目标、建议、实施情况和预期成果。
对与英格兰长期护理机构中COVID-19相关的公开可用政策文件、指导意见和建议进行范围界定审查,通过对英国政府网站进行系统搜索来确定。提取纳入文件中报告的主要目标、建议、实施情况和预期成果。采用三阶段方法进行主题综合分析数据:对文本进行编码、将代码分组为描述性主题以及形成分析性主题。
审查纳入了33份关键政策文件。确定了六个建议领域:感染预防与控制、医院出院、检测与疫苗接种、人员配备、探视和持续常规护理。确定了七个实施领域:资金、合作工作、监测与数据收集、减轻工作量、决策与领导、培训与技术以及沟通。
长期护理机构仍然是复杂的场所,必须从COVID-19期间的经历中吸取教训,以确保未来疫情得到妥善管理。本审查综合了这一时期发布的政策,然而,此类指导意见在多大程度上传达给了长期护理机构并随后得到实施,以及其有效性如何,还需要进一步研究。特别是,需要解决对这些政策的次生影响的理解以及如何在成人社会护理固有的现有挑战范围内引入这些政策的问题。