Department of Radiation Oncology, Stanford University, Stanford, California, USA.
Med Phys. 2024 Jun;51(6):4389-4401. doi: 10.1002/mp.17114. Epub 2024 May 4.
Biology-guided radiotherapy (BgRT) is a novel radiotherapy delivery technique that utilizes the tumor itself to guide dynamic delivery of treatment dose to the tumor. The RefleXion X1 system is the first radiotherapy system developed to deliver SCINTIX® BgRT. The X1 is characterized by its split arc design, employing two 90-degree positron emission tomography (PET) arcs to guide therapeutic radiation beams in real time, currently cleared by FDA to treat bone and lung tumors.
This study aims to comprehensively evaluate the capabilities of the SCINTIX radiotherapy delivery system by evaluating its sensitivity to changes in PET contrast, its adaptability in the context of patient motion, and its performance across a spectrum of prescription doses.
A series of experimental scenarios, both static and dynamic, were designed to assess the SCINTIX BgRT system's performance, including an end-to-end test. These experiments involved a range of factors, including changes in PET contrast, motion, and prescription doses. Measurements were performed using a custom-made ArcCHECK insert which included a 2.2 cm spherical target and a c-shape structure that can be filled with a PET tracer with varying concentrations. Sinusoidal and cosine motion patterns, simulating patient breathing, was used to test the SCINTIX system's ability to deliver BgRT during motion-induced challenges. Each experiment was evaluated against specific metrics, including Activity Concentration (AC), Normalized Target Signal (NTS), and Biology Tracking Zone (BTZ) bounded dose-volume histogram (bDVH) pass rates. The accuracy of the delivered BgRT doses on ArcCHECK and EBT-XD film were evaluated using gamma 3%/2 mm and 3%/3 mm analysis.
In static scenarios, the X1 system consistently demonstrated precision and robustness in SCINTIX dose delivery. The end-to-end delivery to the spherical target yielded good results, with AC and NTS values surpassing the critical thresholds of 5 kBq/mL and 2, respectively. Furthermore, bDVH analysis consistently confirmed 100% pass rates. These results were reaffirmed in scenarios involving changes in PET contrast, emphasizing the system's ability to adapt to varying PET avidities. Gamma analysis with 3%/2 mm (10% dose threshold) criteria consistently achieved pass rates > 91.5% for the static tests. In dynamic SCINTIX delivery scenarios, the X1 system exhibited adaptability under conditions of motion. Sinusoidal and cosine motion patterns resulted in 3%/3 mm gamma pass rates > 87%. Moreover, the comparison with gated stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) delivery on a conventional c-arm Linac resulted in 93.9% gamma pass rates and used as comparison to evaluate the interplay effect. The 1 cm step shift tests showed low overall gamma pass rates of 60.3% in ArcCHECK measurements, while the doses in the PTV agreed with the plan with 99.9% for 3%/3 mm measured with film.
The comprehensive evaluation of the X1 radiotherapy delivery system for SCINTIX BgRT demonstrated good agreement for the static tests. The system consistently achieved critical metrics and delivered the BgRT doses per plan. The motion tests demonstrated its ability to co-localize the dose where the PET signal is and deliver acceptable BgRT dose distributions.
生物学引导放疗(BgRT)是一种新型放疗技术,利用肿瘤本身来引导治疗剂量动态输送至肿瘤。RefleXion X1 系统是第一个开发用于提供 SCINTIX® BgRT 的放疗系统。X1 的特点是其分裂弧设计,使用两个 90 度正电子发射断层扫描(PET)弧实时引导治疗射线束,目前已获得 FDA 批准用于治疗骨和肺部肿瘤。
本研究旨在通过评估 SCINTIX 放疗系统对 PET 对比度变化的敏感性、在患者运动背景下的适应性以及在一系列处方剂量下的性能,全面评估 SCINTIX 放疗系统的性能。
设计了一系列静态和动态的实验场景来评估 SCINTIX BgRT 系统的性能,包括端到端测试。这些实验涉及一系列因素,包括 PET 对比度变化、运动和处方剂量。使用定制的 ArcCHECK 插件进行测量,该插件包括一个 2.2cm 的球形目标和一个 C 形结构,可以用不同浓度的 PET 示踪剂填充。使用模拟患者呼吸的正弦和余弦运动模式来测试 SCINTIX 系统在运动引起的挑战下提供 BgRT 的能力。每个实验都根据特定的指标进行评估,包括活性浓度(AC)、归一化靶信号(NTS)和生物学跟踪区(BTZ)有界剂量体积直方图(bDVH)通过率。使用伽马 3%/2mm 和 3%/3mm 分析评估 ArcCHECK 和 EBT-XD 胶片上的 BgRT 剂量的准确性。
在静态场景中,X1 系统在 SCINTIX 剂量输送方面始终表现出精度和稳健性。对球形靶标的端到端输送产生了良好的结果,AC 和 NTS 值分别超过了 5kBq/mL 和 2 的关键阈值。此外,bDVH 分析一致确认了 100%的通过率。在涉及 PET 亲和力变化的场景中,这些结果得到了进一步证实,强调了系统适应不同 PET 活性的能力。使用 3%/2mm(10%剂量阈值)标准的伽马分析在静态测试中始终实现了>91.5%的通过率。在动态 SCINTIX 输送场景中,X1 系统在运动条件下表现出适应性。正弦和余弦运动模式导致 3%/3mm 伽马通过率>87%。此外,与传统 C 臂直线加速器上的门控立体定向体放射治疗(SBRT)输送进行比较,伽马通过率为 93.9%,并使用其来评估互作用效应。在 ArcCHECK 测量中,1cm 步移测试的总体伽马通过率为 60.3%,而 PTV 中的剂量与计划一致,使用胶片测量的 3%/3mm 伽马通过率为 99.9%。
对 X1 放疗系统用于 SCINTIX BgRT 的全面评估表明,静态测试结果良好一致。该系统始终达到关键指标并按计划输送 BgRT 剂量。运动测试表明,它能够将剂量与 PET 信号所在的位置相匹配,并提供可接受的 BgRT 剂量分布。