Rivara F P, Culley G A, Hickok D, Williams R L
Department of Pediatrics, University of Washington, Seattle 98104.
Am J Prev Med. 1985 May-Jun;1(3):35-40.
We examined the impact of an innovative rural health program in central Appalachia on neonatal mortality by comparing improvements in the neonatal mortality rates of the serviced counties to those of the 13 control counties. Using data on all births and neonatal deaths in the study and control counties from 1970 to 1978 (tabulated by mother's county of residence), an expected neonatal mortality rate of each county was calculated by standardizing for the most important risk components: birth weight, sex, and birth multiplicity. An index of medical care effectiveness, the standardized mortality rate (SMR) for the study and control counties was computed by dividing the observed neonatal mortality rate by the expected rate. The SMRs of the study and control counties were then compared using a standard normal test statistic. The results indicated that the SMRs were significantly different in the control and study counties in the preintervention period 1970-1972. In subsequent years the SMRs converged, resulting in nearly equal rates for 1977-1978. The improvement in neonatal mortality in both areas may be due to their improved economic status rather than health care alone.
我们通过比较受服务县与13个对照县的新生儿死亡率改善情况,研究了阿巴拉契亚中部一项创新性农村健康项目对新生儿死亡率的影响。利用1970年至1978年研究县和对照县所有出生和新生儿死亡的数据(按母亲居住县列表),通过对最重要的风险因素:出生体重、性别和出生胎次进行标准化,计算出每个县的预期新生儿死亡率。通过将观察到的新生儿死亡率除以预期死亡率,计算出研究县和对照县的医疗保健有效性指数——标准化死亡率(SMR)。然后使用标准正态检验统计量比较研究县和对照县的SMR。结果表明,在1970 - 1972年干预前期,对照县和研究县的SMR存在显著差异。在随后几年中,SMR趋于一致,导致1977 - 1978年的比率几乎相等。两个地区新生儿死亡率的改善可能是由于经济状况的改善,而不仅仅是医疗保健。