Brocco Giorgio
Department of Social and Cultural Anthropology, University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Front Health Serv. 2024 Apr 25;4:1261091. doi: 10.3389/frhs.2024.1261091. eCollection 2024.
"Critical disability studies" (CDS) is an interdisciplinary field of research that examines social, political, economic, racial, gendered and historical constructions of bodily non-normativity across different geopolitical areas and scales. Despite its diverse and multiple contributions and objectives, current research in critical disability studies has been described as mainly focusing on disability issues in the Global North and as having universalizing tendencies. In this context, intersubjective perspectives and empirical data offered by ethnographic works in medical and disability anthropology and related disciplines have been either in accord or tension with the broader field of CDS. On the one hand, this review article illustrates the many ways anthropologists have adopted various research perspectives to explore bodily non-normativity outside settings in the Global North. On the other, it shows the importance of research by anthropologists working on topics related to disability, as well as their recent fruitful collaborations with CDS scholars and approaches. By exploring these epistemological and empirical entanglements, this paper concludes that deeper engagements between CDS and anthropology, as well as a more thorough focus on the ethnographic analysis of bodily non-normativity, can open new creative routes for the analysis of disability in various world contexts.
“批判性残疾研究”(CDS)是一个跨学科研究领域,它考察不同地缘政治区域和规模下身体非规范性的社会、政治、经济、种族、性别及历史建构。尽管批判性残疾研究有多样且多元的贡献和目标,但当前该领域的研究被描述为主要聚焦于全球北方的残疾问题且具有普遍化倾向。在这种背景下,医学与残疾人类学及相关学科的民族志作品所提供的主体间视角和实证数据,与批判性残疾研究的更广泛领域既存在一致之处,也存在紧张关系。一方面,这篇综述文章阐述了人类学家采用各种研究视角在全球北方以外的背景下探索身体非规范性的多种方式。另一方面,它展示了研究残疾相关主题的人类学家开展研究的重要性,以及他们近期与批判性残疾研究学者及方法进行的富有成效的合作。通过探究这些认识论和实证方面的纠葛,本文得出结论:批判性残疾研究与人类学之间更深入的互动,以及对身体非规范性的民族志分析更全面的关注,能够为在各种世界背景下分析残疾问题开辟新的创造性路径。