Jockey Club School of Public Health and Primary Care, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China.
Centre for Health Systems & Policy Research, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China.
Telemed J E Health. 2024 Aug;30(8):e2335-e2343. doi: 10.1089/tmj.2023.0635. Epub 2024 May 14.
Telemedicine has been widely used during the COVID-19 pandemic. Among other health care professionals, Chinese medicine practitioners (CMPs) face practical challenges in providing telemedicine consultations. This study aims to explore CMPs' experience and perceptions of telemedicine service provision before and during the pandemic. A territory-wide cross-sectional online survey was conducted in Hong Kong between April and May 2022. A structured questionnaire with open-ended questions was used to investigate the provision of and perception on telemedicine service, as well as usability of telemedicine among CMPs. A total of 195 CMPs participated the survey. Before COVID-19, 42% (81/195) had been providing telemedicine services, and the proportion doubled during COVID-19. CMPs in the private sector are the main providers. Mobile apps including WhatsApp, WeChat, and Zoom were commonly used for consultations (75%, 120/161). Barriers in providing telemedicine included inability of conducting physical examination on patients (69%, 134/195), legal and ethical concerns over medical negligence (61%, 118/195), and patients' incompetence on e-literacy (50%, 98/195). Respondents urged professional and regulatory bodies to provide an explicit clinical guideline that demonstrate best practice in traditional Chinese medicine telemedicine, and to clarify legal and ethical implications of such practice. CMPs demonstrated their competency in telemedicine, and most of them provided telemedicine during COVID-19. Development of appropriate guidelines on the provision of telemedicine would support CMPs to continue provision after the pandemic, whereas a user-friendly and comprehensive telemedicine e-platform would enhance quality of such service. Facilitating patients with lower e-literacy to access telemedicine is key to reduce disparities.
远程医疗在 COVID-19 大流行期间得到了广泛应用。在其他医疗保健专业人员中,中医师(CMP)在提供远程医疗咨询方面面临实际挑战。本研究旨在探讨 CMP 在大流行前后提供远程医疗服务的经验和看法。
2022 年 4 月至 5 月,在香港进行了一项全港范围的横断面在线调查。使用带有开放式问题的结构化问卷,调查了 CMP 提供远程医疗服务的情况和对远程医疗服务的看法,以及远程医疗的可用性。共有 195 名 CMP 参加了调查。在 COVID-19 之前,有 42%(195 名中的 81 名)已经提供远程医疗服务,而在 COVID-19 期间,这一比例增加了一倍。私营部门的 CMP 是主要提供者。WhatsApp、WeChat 和 Zoom 等移动应用程序常用于咨询(75%,161 名中的 120 名)。提供远程医疗的障碍包括无法对患者进行体检(69%,195 名中的 134 名)、对医疗疏忽的法律和道德担忧(61%,195 名中的 118 名)以及患者对电子扫盲的能力不足(50%,195 名中的 98 名)。受访者敦促专业和监管机构提供明确的临床指南,展示传统中医远程医疗的最佳实践,并澄清这种实践的法律和道德含义。
CMP 展示了他们在远程医疗方面的能力,他们大多数人在 COVID-19 期间提供远程医疗服务。制定关于提供远程医疗服务的适当指南将支持 CMP 在大流行后继续提供服务,而用户友好且全面的远程医疗电子平台将提高此类服务的质量。为了减少差距,关键是要让电子扫盲水平较低的患者能够获得远程医疗服务。