Quantitative Data Science Methods, The University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany.
Department of Sociology, Chung-Ang University, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
PLoS One. 2024 May 16;19(5):e0302373. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0302373. eCollection 2024.
Which kinds of grievances garner support from the public on online platforms? Focusing on national online petitioning, one of the forms of direct democracy in contemporary politics, we examine the content and characteristics of petitions that succeeded in attracting public attention and support. Using our comprehensive data on online petitions that were submitted to the executive office between 2017 and 2022 in South Korea, our analysis yields three important findings. First, a mix of post-materialist topics such as human rights and gender equality and materialist topics such as safety and environment turn out to be salient among petitions that meet the signature threshold. Second, online petitions the contents of which reveal either moral emotions or Confucian attitudes are more likely to gain public support compared to others. Third, keywords that are related to moral claims asking for the apprehension of perpetrators on behalf of victims, such as 'victim,' 'perpetrator,' 'kid,' and 'punishment,' appear most frequently inside the petitions that cross the signature threshold. Such findings provide implications for understanding both the potentials and limitations of national online petitioning in contemporary democracies.
哪些冤情能在网络平台上获得公众支持?本文聚焦于当代政治中直接民主的一种形式——国家网络请愿,研究了成功吸引公众关注和支持的请愿书的内容和特点。我们利用韩国在 2017 年至 2022 年期间向行政办公室提交的全面网络请愿数据,分析得出了三个重要发现。首先,在达到签名门槛的请愿书中,出现了后物质主义话题(如人权和性别平等)和物质主义话题(如安全和环境)的混合。其次,与其他请愿书相比,内容显示出道德情感或儒家态度的网络请愿更有可能获得公众支持。第三,与代表受害者要求逮捕犯罪者的道德主张相关的关键词,如“受害者”、“犯罪者”、“孩子”和“惩罚”,在越过签名门槛的请愿书中出现的频率最高。这些发现为理解当代民主国家的国家网络请愿的潜力和局限性提供了启示。