Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Concordia University, Room H-1125.44, 1455 de Maisonneuve Blvd. W., QC H3G 1 Mb, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Department of Sociology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Z Gerontol Geriatr. 2024 Jul;57(4):266-271. doi: 10.1007/s00391-024-02310-7. Epub 2024 May 18.
Narrative gerontology considers how people age biographically as well as socially and biologically. Vulnerability as a process category and state of being remains undertheorized in the context of narratives of later life. It is argued that the narrative space for stories from old age privilege backward-looking stories that focus on positive milestones and support cultural narratives of a "life well lived." Sad, emotionally laden or uncertain/unfinished stories that reveal vulnerabilities are rejected and potentially viewed as problematic. Using an illustrative case example of a study of resilience narratives and aging, this paper considers how the study authors position and identify resilience. Some interpretative judgements used in the research regarding who is resilient based on expressions of vulnerability are highlighted. Overall, the tensions between cultural and personal narratives that position older people as vulnerable subjects are considered and it is argued that vulnerability can be a great source of strength and meaning in later life.
叙事老年学考虑了人们在传记、社会和生物层面上的衰老方式。在关于晚年生活的叙述中,脆弱性作为一个过程类别和存在状态仍然没有得到充分的理论化。有人认为,老年故事的叙事空间偏向于回顾性的故事,这些故事关注积极的里程碑,并支持“美好生活”的文化叙事。悲伤、情感负荷或不确定/未完成的揭示脆弱性的故事被拒绝,并可能被视为有问题的。本文通过一个关于韧性叙事和老龄化研究的案例示例,考虑了研究作者如何定位和识别韧性。研究中基于脆弱性表达来确定谁具有韧性时所使用的一些解释性判断被突出显示。总体而言,本文考虑了将老年人定位为脆弱主体的文化和个人叙事之间的紧张关系,并认为脆弱性在晚年生活中可以成为力量和意义的重要来源。