University of Bern, Faculty of Medicine, Institute for Medical Education, Bern, Switzerland.
Inselspital, Bern University Hospital, University of Bern, Department of Dermatology, Bern, Switzerland.
GMS J Med Educ. 2024 Apr 15;41(2):Doc14. doi: 10.3205/zma001669. eCollection 2024.
Modern medical moulages are becoming increasingly important in simulation-based health professions education. Their lifelikeness is important so that simulation engagement is not disrupted while their standardization is crucial in high-stakes exams. This report describes in detail how three-dimensional transfers are developed and produced so that educators will be able to develop their own. In addition, evaluation findings and lessons learnt from deploying transfers in summative assessments are shared. Step-by-step instructions are given for the creation and application of transfers, including materials and photographic visualizations. We also examined feedback on 10 exam stations (out of a total of 81) with self-developed three-dimensional transfers and complement this with additional lessons learnt. By the time of submission, the authors successfully developed and deployed over 40 different three-dimensional transfers representing different clinical findings in high-stakes exams using the techniques explained in this article or variations thereof. Feedback from students and examiners after completing the OSCE is predominantly positive, with lifelikeness being the quality most often commented upon. Caveats derived from feedback and own experiences are included. The step-by-step approach reported can be adapted and replicated by healthcare educators to build their own three-dimensional transfers. This should widen the scope and the lifelikeness of their simulations. At the same time we propose that this level of lifelikeness should be expected by learners as not to disrupt simulation engagement. Our evaluation of their use in high-stakes assessments suggests they are both useful and accepted.
现代医学模拟在基于模拟的健康专业教育中变得越来越重要。它们的逼真度很重要,这样模拟参与就不会被打断,而它们的标准化在高风险考试中至关重要。本报告详细描述了如何开发和制作三维转移模型,以便教育工作者能够开发自己的转移模型。此外,还分享了在总结性评估中部署转移模型的评估结果和经验教训。提供了创建和应用转移模型的分步说明,包括材料和摄影可视化。我们还检查了使用本文中解释的技术或其变体在 10 个考试站(总共 81 个)中开发和部署的自我开发的三维转移模型的反馈,并补充了其他经验教训。在提交时,作者成功地开发和部署了 40 多个不同的三维转移模型,代表了高风险考试中的不同临床发现。学生和考官在完成 OSCE 后的反馈主要是积极的,逼真度是最常被评论的质量。反馈和自身经验得出的注意事项也包括在内。所报告的分步方法可以被医疗保健教育工作者改编和复制,以建立自己的三维转移模型。这应该扩大他们模拟的范围和逼真度。同时,我们建议学习者应该期望达到这种逼真度,以免打断模拟参与。我们对它们在高风险评估中的使用的评估表明,它们既有用又被接受。