Shin Mikyung, Hart Stephanie L, Simmons Michelle
Department of Education, Center for Learning Disabilities, West Texas A&M University.
Sch Psychol. 2024 Nov;39(6):625-635. doi: 10.1037/spq0000637. Epub 2024 May 23.
This study describes the benefits and challenges of meta-analyses of single-case design research using multilevel modeling. The researchers illustrate procedures for conducting meta-analyses using four-level multilevel modeling through open-source R code. The demonstration uses data from multiple-baseline or multiple-probe across-participant single-case design studies ( = 21) on word problem instruction for students with learning disabilities published between 1975 and 2023. Researchers explore changes in levels and trends between adjacent phases (baseline vs. intervention and intervention vs. maintenance) using the sample data. The researchers conclude that word problem solving of students with learning disabilities varies based on the complexity of the word problem measures involving single-word problem, mixed-word problem, and generalization questions. These moderating effects differed across adjacent phases. These findings extend previous literature on meta-analyses methodology by describing how multilevel modeling can be used to compare the impacts of time-varying predictors within and across cases when analyzing single-case design studies. Future researchers may want to use this methodology to explore the roles of time-varying predictors as well as case or study-level moderators. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
本研究描述了使用多层次建模对单案例设计研究进行元分析的益处和挑战。研究人员通过开源R代码说明了使用四级多层次建模进行元分析的程序。该演示使用了1975年至2023年期间发表的关于学习障碍学生应用题教学的跨参与者单案例设计研究( = 21)中的多基线或多探针数据。研究人员使用样本数据探索相邻阶段(基线与干预以及干预与维持)之间水平和趋势的变化。研究人员得出结论,学习障碍学生的应用题解决能力因应用题测量的复杂性而异,应用题测量包括单字问题、混合字问题和概括性问题。这些调节效应在相邻阶段有所不同。这些发现通过描述在分析单案例设计研究时如何使用多层次建模来比较案例内和案例间随时间变化的预测因素的影响,扩展了先前关于元分析方法的文献。未来的研究人员可能希望使用这种方法来探索随时间变化的预测因素以及案例或研究水平调节因素的作用。(PsycInfo数据库记录(c)2024美国心理学会,保留所有权利)