Department of Global Health, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, United States of America.
Department of Surgery, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2024 May 24;19(5):e0300458. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0300458. eCollection 2024.
Road traffic collisions disproportionately impact Ghana and other low- and middle-income countries. This study explored road user perspectives regarding the magnitude, contributing factors, and potential solutions to road traffic collisions, injuries, and deaths. We designed a qualitative study of 24 in-depth interviews with 14 vulnerable road users (pedestrians, occupants of powered 2- and 3-wheelers, cyclists) and ten non-vulnerable road users in four high-risk areas in November 2022. We used a mixed deductive (direct content analysis) and inductive (interpretive phenomenological analysis) approach. In the direct content analysis, a priori categories based on Haddon's Matrix covered human, vehicle, socioeconomic environment, and physical environment factors influencing road traffic collisions, along with corresponding solutions. We used inductive analysis to identify emerging themes. Participants described frequent and distressing experiences with collisions, and most often reported contributing factors, implementation gaps, and potential solutions within the human (road user) level domain of Haddon's Matrix. Implementation challenges included sporadic enforcement, reliance on road users' adherence to safety laws, and the low quality of the existing infrastructure. Participants expressed that they felt neglected and ignored by road safety decision-makers. This research emphasizes the need for community input for successful road safety policies in Ghana and other low- and middle-income countries, calling for greater governmental support an action to address this public health crisis. We recommend the government collaborates with communities to adapt existing interventions including speed calming, footbridges, and police enforcement, and introduces new measures that meet local needs.
道路交通碰撞不成比例地影响加纳和其他中低收入国家。本研究探讨了道路使用者对道路交通碰撞、伤害和死亡的规模、促成因素和潜在解决方案的看法。我们设计了一项定性研究,对 2022 年 11 月在加纳四个高风险地区的 14 名弱势道路使用者(行人、两轮和三轮机动车乘客、骑自行车的人)和 10 名非弱势道路使用者进行了 24 次深入访谈。我们采用了混合演绎(直接内容分析)和归纳(解释现象学分析)方法。在直接内容分析中,基于 Haddon 矩阵的先验类别涵盖了影响道路交通碰撞的人为、车辆、社会经济环境和物理环境因素,以及相应的解决方案。我们采用归纳分析来识别新出现的主题。参与者描述了频繁和令人痛苦的碰撞经历,大多数人报告了促成因素、实施差距和 Haddon 矩阵中人为(道路使用者)领域的潜在解决方案。实施挑战包括零星执法、依赖道路使用者遵守安全法规以及现有基础设施质量低下。参与者表示,他们感到被道路安全决策者忽视和忽视。这项研究强调了加纳和其他中低收入国家需要社区投入以制定成功的道路安全政策,呼吁政府提供更多支持和采取行动应对这一公共卫生危机。我们建议政府与社区合作,调整现有的干预措施,包括限速、人行天桥和警察执法,并引入符合当地需求的新措施。