O'Neill Ciaran, Crealey Grainne E
Centre for Public Health, Institute of Clinical Sciences, Royal Victoria Hospital, Belfast BT12 6BA, UK.
Clinical Costing Solutions, Belfast BT15 4EB, UK.
Vaccines (Basel). 2024 May 10;12(5):523. doi: 10.3390/vaccines12050523.
Influenza vaccination is an important public health measure that can reduce disease burden, especially among older persons (those aged 65 and over) who have weaker immune systems. Evidence suggests enhanced vaccines, including adjuvanted quadrivalent vaccines (aQIV), may be particularly effective in this group. This study reports the results of a systematic review of the cost-effectiveness of aQIV in this population. The review was undertaken and reported in accordance with good practice guidelines. Medline and EMBASE were searched from 2013 to the present. Pre-selected eligibility criteria were employed and quality assessment undertaken using the Consensus Health Economic Criteria (CHEC-extended) checklist and Consolidated Health Economic Evaluation Reporting Standard (CHEERS) 2022 checklists. A total of 124 records were returned, with 10 full text papers retained. All were modelling studies and exhibited heterogeneity in approach, perspective, and parameter estimation. Nine papers reported cost-effectiveness ranging from EUR 6694/QALY to EUR 20,000/QALY in evaluations employing a payer perspective and from EUR 3936/QALY to EUR 17,200/QALY in those using a societal perspective. Results remained robust to a range of sensitivity analyses. One paper that reported contrary findings adopted a distinct modelling approach. It is reasonable to conclude that there is a broad consensus as to the cost-effectiveness of aQIV in this population group.
流感疫苗接种是一项重要的公共卫生措施,可减轻疾病负担,尤其是在免疫系统较弱的老年人(65岁及以上)中。有证据表明,包括佐剂四价疫苗(aQIV)在内的增强型疫苗可能对该群体特别有效。本研究报告了对aQIV在该人群中的成本效益进行系统评价的结果。该评价是按照良好实践指南进行并报告的。检索了2013年至今的Medline和EMBASE。采用预先选定的纳入标准,并使用共识卫生经济标准(CHEC扩展版)清单和2022年综合卫生经济评价报告标准(CHEERS)清单进行质量评估。共检索到124条记录,保留了10篇全文论文。所有研究均为模型研究,在方法、视角和参数估计方面存在异质性。9篇论文报告了成本效益,采用支付方视角的评价中成本效益范围为每质量调整生命年6694欧元至20000欧元,采用社会视角的评价中成本效益范围为每质量调整生命年3936欧元至17200欧元。一系列敏感性分析的结果仍然稳健。一篇报告了相反结果的论文采用了独特的建模方法。可以合理地得出结论,对于aQIV在该人群中的成本效益存在广泛共识。