Chua Ker Yang, Paranchothy Malini, Ng Su Fang, Lee Chee Chan
Department of Paediatrics, Hospital Tunku Azizah, Ministry of Health, Malaysia.
Department of Paediatrics, Hospital Likas, Ministry of Health, Malaysia.
Indian J Palliat Care. 2024 Apr-Jun;30(2):182-186. doi: 10.25259/IJPC_304_2023. Epub 2024 May 2.
Non-invasive ventilation (NIV), namely continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) and bi-level positive airway pressure (BiPAP), delivers mechanical ventilation without endotracheal intubation. Short-term NIV (planned for <21 days during initiation) can be used for the management of acute respiratory distress (ARD) among paediatric palliative patients with "Do Not Resuscitate or Intubate" (DNI) as the ceiling of care. This study aimed to describe the usage of short-term NIV among paediatric palliative patients in a woman and child hospital with a paediatric palliative subspecialty.
A retrospective and observational study was conducted on all paediatric palliative patients who received short-term NIV in Tunku Azizah Hospital Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, from March 2020 to May 2022.
During the study period, short-term NIV was offered on 23 occasions for 20 different children. Indications for short-term NIV include 16 (69.6%) occasions of potentially reversible ARD (NIV Category 1) and 7 (30.4%) occasions of comfort care at the end of life (NIV Category 2). The main cause of ARD was pneumonia (90.3%) due to either aspiration or infection. The modality of NIV used was BiPAP only (14 occasions, 60.9%), CPAP only (three occasions, 13%) and both BiPAP and CPAP (six occasions, 26.1%). The median duration of NIV usage was four days (minimum one day and maximum 15 days). NIV was initiated as an escalation from nasal prong, Ventimask or high-flow mask oxygen on 22 occasions and as weaning down post-extubation on one occasion. For the 22 occasions of escalating therapy, there was significant improvement at six hours compared to pre-NIV in the median heart rate (136 to 121, =0.002), respiratory rate (40 to 31, =0.002) and oxygen saturation (96% to 99%, =0.025). All 17 documented parental impressions of the child's condition post six hours of NIV were that the child had improved. Adverse events during short-term NIV include five episodes (21.7%) of stomach distension, four episodes (17.4%) of skin sores on the face and one episode (4.3%) of excessive drooling. Three patients passed away while on NIV in the hospital. For the other 20 (87%) occasions, patients were able to wean off NIV. Post-weaning off NIV, three patients passed away during the same admission. On 17 occasions, patients were discharged home after weaning off NIV.
Usage of short-term NIV in paediatric palliative care, where children have an advanced directive in place indicating DNI, as seen in our study, can be a valuable modality of management for distressing symptoms, in addition to the pharmacological management of breathlessness. This is shown through our study to be of benefit in potentially reversible ARD as well as comfort care at the end of life. Further rigorous studies will need to be conducted for a clearer understanding of short-term NIV that would enable the formulation of guidelines to improve the quality of life and death in children.
无创通气(NIV),即持续气道正压通气(CPAP)和双水平气道正压通气(BiPAP),无需气管插管即可提供机械通气。短期NIV(启动时计划使用时间<21天)可用于以“不要复苏或插管”(DNI)作为最高护理限度的儿科姑息治疗患者的急性呼吸窘迫(ARD)管理。本研究旨在描述一家设有儿科姑息治疗专科的妇幼医院中儿科姑息治疗患者短期NIV的使用情况。
对2020年3月至2022年5月在马来西亚吉隆坡敦库阿齐扎医院接受短期NIV的所有儿科姑息治疗患者进行了一项回顾性观察研究。
在研究期间,共为20名不同儿童提供了23次短期NIV。短期NIV的适应证包括16次(69.6%)潜在可逆性ARD(NIV 1类)和7次(30.4%)临终时的舒适护理(NIV 2类)。ARD的主要原因是因误吸或感染导致的肺炎(90.3%)。使用的NIV模式仅为BiPAP(14次,60.9%)、仅CPAP(3次,13%)以及BiPAP和CPAP联合使用(6次,26.1%)。NIV使用的中位持续时间为4天(最短1天,最长15天)。NIV有22次是从鼻导管、Ventimask或高流量面罩吸氧升级开始的,有1次是在拔管后逐渐减量。在22次升级治疗中,与NIV治疗前相比,中位心率(从136次/分钟降至121次/分钟,P = 0.002)、呼吸频率(从40次/分钟降至31次/分钟,P = 0.002)和血氧饱和度(从96%升至99%,P = 0.025)在6小时时有显著改善。记录的所有17例家长对NIV治疗6小时后孩子状况的印象均表明孩子有所改善。短期NIV期间的不良事件包括5次(21.7%)腹胀、4次(17.4%)面部皮肤溃疡和1次(4.3%)流涎过多。3例患者在医院接受NIV治疗期间死亡。在其他20次(87%)情况下,患者能够撤机。撤机后,3例患者在同一住院期间死亡。17次情况下,患者在撤机后出院回家。
如我们的研究所示,在儿科姑息治疗中,当儿童有DNI的预先指示时,短期NIV除了用于呼吸困难的药物治疗外,还可以作为一种有价值的管理方式来缓解痛苦症状。我们的研究表明,这对潜在可逆性ARD以及临终时的舒适护理有益。需要进行进一步严格的研究,以更清楚地了解短期NIV,从而制定指南以改善儿童的生活质量和死亡质量。