Khorwal Gitanjali, Meshram Raviprakash, Vaibhav Vikas, Sharma Rahul, Singh Brijendra, Chandran Salu, Sharma Kshitiza
Anatomy, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Rishikesh, Rishikesh, IND.
Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Rishikesh, Rishikesh, IND.
Cureus. 2024 May 7;16(5):e59809. doi: 10.7759/cureus.59809. eCollection 2024 May.
Background Students' presentations are a teaching-learning tool where students not only study and understand a topic but also teach their peers, thereby learning the art and skill of effective presentation. Aims The study aimed to evaluate peer assessments in students' presentations and find their role and application in improving presentation skills among students through feedback and course correction. Methods A group of students every week from a class of 125 was assigned a topic to present to the rest of their batch students who evaluated their presentation on a rubric shared via a Google Form link. The number of students who gave responses was noted. The responses were also shared with the presenters. The evaluator faculty moderated and discussed the areas for possible improvement and course correction. The students also filled out a feedback form on the entire exercise after presentations from the entire batch. Results The quality of students' presentation skills improved with subsequent students over the period. The students learned about their areas of improvement. Through the feedback form, students shared their reasons not to give a presentation. However, most of them found the exercise beneficial. Conclusions Peer assessment can be a credible mode for improving presentation skills with the active participation of other students and provide a learning method based on others' performances. Peer responses provide for self-evaluation and self-reflection. This type of survey among different institutions will identify students' flaws, help them improve and self-evaluate, and add to the current literature.
学生展示是一种教学工具,学生不仅要学习和理解一个主题,还要向同龄人传授知识,从而学习有效展示的艺术和技巧。
本研究旨在评估学生展示中的同伴评估,并通过反馈和课程纠正,找出其在提高学生展示技巧方面的作用和应用。
每周从125名学生的班级中选出一组学生,分配一个主题,让他们向同批次的其他学生进行展示,其他学生通过谷歌表单链接共享的评分标准对其展示进行评估。记录给出反馈的学生人数。反馈也会分享给展示者。评估教师进行审核,并讨论可能需要改进和纠正的方面。在整个班级的学生都完成展示后,学生们还要填写一份关于整个活动的反馈表。
在这段时间里,学生展示技巧的质量随着后续学生的表现而提高。学生们了解到了自己需要改进的方面。通过反馈表,学生们分享了他们不进行展示的原因。然而,他们中的大多数人都认为这个活动是有益的。
在其他学生的积极参与下,同伴评估可以成为提高展示技巧的可靠方式,并提供一种基于他人表现的学习方法。同伴反馈有助于自我评估和自我反思。在不同机构中进行此类调查将找出学生的不足之处,帮助他们改进和自我评估,并丰富现有文献。