Tang Yike, Qian Ping, Yan Linlin
Zhejiang Sci-Tech University, Hangzhou, China.
Iperception. 2024 Jun 5;15(3):20416695241259160. doi: 10.1177/20416695241259160. eCollection 2024 May-Jun.
Numerous studies have consistently demonstrated the presence of the approximate number system (ANS) throughout development. Research has also revealed that visual cues may influence the ANS acuity, which may change with age. However, most studies have drawn conclusions based on performance differences between incongruent and congruent trials, which may be confounded by an individual's ability to inhibit interference. Therefore, to examine the developmental changes of the impact of visual cues on ANS acuity, we utilized congruent trials with varying visual cues. Our sample comprised Chinese children from grade one to grade five. We manipulated the salience of numerical cues (numerical ratio) and visual cues (dot size) in a non-symbolic numerosity comparison task. The results revealed a discernible leap in development from first to third grade and first to fifth grade; however, this upward trajectory did not persist into the transition from third to fifth grade, where no appreciable advancement was observed. Moreover, we observed different effects of visual cues on the dot-comparison task depending on the numerical cues and age. Specifically, visual cues (i.e., dot size) only facilitated ANS acuity in older school-aged children when numerical cues were weakened. The results indicate the presence of two distinct magnitude representational systems-one for the numerical dimension and another for the non-numerical dimension-during development.
众多研究一致表明,近似数字系统(ANS)在整个发育过程中都存在。研究还发现,视觉线索可能会影响ANS敏锐度,而ANS敏锐度可能会随年龄变化。然而,大多数研究都是基于不一致试验和一致试验之间的表现差异得出结论的,而这种差异可能会因个体抑制干扰的能力而混淆。因此,为了研究视觉线索对ANS敏锐度影响的发育变化,我们使用了具有不同视觉线索的一致试验。我们的样本包括来自一年级到五年级的中国儿童。在一项非符号数量比较任务中,我们操纵了数字线索(数字比例)和视觉线索(点的大小)的显著性。结果显示,从一年级到三年级以及从一年级到五年级,发育过程中有明显的飞跃;然而,这种上升趋势在从三年级到五年级的过渡中并未持续,在这一阶段未观察到明显进展。此外,我们观察到视觉线索对点数比较任务的影响因数字线索和年龄而异。具体而言,当数字线索减弱时,视觉线索(即点的大小)仅在年龄较大的学龄儿童中促进了ANS敏锐度。结果表明,在发育过程中存在两种不同的数量表征系统——一种用于数字维度,另一种用于非数字维度。