Rosner D, Blaird D
J Surg Oncol. 1985 Apr;28(4):308-13. doi: 10.1002/jso.2930280415.
The capability of ultrasonography to provide additional information to the physical and mammographic examination for therapeutic decision was investigated in a prospective study. Four hundred patients with palpable or radiologic breast masses requiring surgical biopsy were studied. The high resolution and accuracy of ultrasonography vs. mammography in the diagnosis of cystic masses (96%, 63/66 vs. 42%, 20/48) (p less than 0.001) and fibrocystic masses (84%, 131/156 vs. 74%, 80/108) (p less than 0.10), led to a substantial reduction of surgical biopsies in favor of aspiration or follow-up policy, particularly when physical examination and mammography were inconclusive. Breast cancers were accurately diagnosed in 73% (88/120) by sonography and 84% (98/116) by mammography (p greater than 0.10). The major limitation of ultrasonography was noticed in the diagnosis of minimal breast cancer (23%, 5/21) due to its inability to visualize microcalcifications. Our study validates the importance of ultrasonography in the diagnosis and therapeutic decision of cystic and fibrocystic masses but cannot substitute mammography in early detection of breast carcinoma.
一项前瞻性研究调查了超声检查在为治疗决策提供体格检查和乳房X线检查之外的额外信息方面的能力。研究了400例需要进行手术活检的可触及或影像学发现乳房肿块的患者。超声检查在诊断囊性肿块(96%,66例中的63例 vs. 42%,48例中的20例)(p<0.001)和纤维囊性肿块(84%,156例中的131例 vs. 74%,108例中的80例)(p<0.10)方面相对于乳房X线检查具有更高的分辨率和准确性,这使得手术活检显著减少,更倾向于采取抽吸或随访策略,尤其是在体格检查和乳房X线检查结果不明确时。超声检查准确诊断出73%(120例中的88例)的乳腺癌,乳房X线检查准确诊断出84%(116例中的98例)的乳腺癌(p>0.10)。超声检查的主要局限性在于诊断微小乳腺癌时(23%,21例中的5例),因为它无法显示微钙化。我们的研究证实了超声检查在囊性和纤维囊性肿块的诊断及治疗决策中的重要性,但在乳腺癌的早期检测中不能替代乳房X线检查。