Tanaka Tsukasa, Kubota Atsushi, Ozaki Hayao, Nishio Hirofumi, Nozu Shojiro, Takazawa Yuji
Juntendo Iji Zasshi. 2023 Nov 16;69(6):477-484. doi: 10.14789/jmj.JMJ23-0014-OA. eCollection 2023.
This study aimed to determine the effects of high-intensity isokinetic training with blood flow restriction during rest interval between set (rBFR) versus during exercise (eBFR) on muscle hypertrophy and increasing muscle strength and determine whether BFR-induced exercise pain is suppressed by rBFR.
Fourteen arms (7 participants) were recruited for the study. We conducted the following interventions for each arm: eBFR (n=4), rBFR (n=5), and exercise only (CON, n=5). The participants performed elbow flexion training with a BIODEX device twice weekly for 8 weeks. This study training consisted of total four sets; each was performed until <50% peak torque was achieved twice consecutively. BFR pressure was set at 120 mmHg. Elbow flexor peak torque during concentric contraction (CC), isometric contraction (IM), and muscle cross-sectional area (CSA) were measured before and after the intervention. Numerical rating scale scores used to assess pain during exercise were determined during training.
Peak torque at the CC increased in the rBFR (p<0.05) and IM increased in the rBFR and CON (p<0.05), while CSA increased in the rBFR and CON (p<0.001). The pain during exercise was severe in the eBFR and moderate in the rBFR and CON.
This study's showed that high-intensity isokinetic training with rBFR did not have a synergistic effect on increasing muscle strength and muscle size. Additionally, high-intensity isokinetic training with BFR when it may be best not to perform it during exercise, because it was induces severe pain and may inhibit increases in muscle strength.
本研究旨在确定在组间休息期间进行血流限制的高强度等速训练(rBFR)与运动期间进行血流限制的高强度等速训练(eBFR)对肌肉肥大、增加肌肉力量的影响,并确定rBFR是否能抑制BFR诱导的运动疼痛。
招募了14只手臂(7名参与者)进行本研究。我们对每只手臂进行了以下干预:eBFR(n = 4)、rBFR(n = 5)和仅运动(对照组,n = 5)。参与者每周使用BIODEX设备进行两次肘部屈曲训练,共8周。本研究训练共包括四组;每组训练至连续两次达到<50%的峰值扭矩。BFR压力设定为120 mmHg。在干预前后测量了向心收缩(CC)、等长收缩(IM)期间的肘部屈肌峰值扭矩以及肌肉横截面积(CSA)。在训练期间确定用于评估运动期间疼痛的数字评分量表分数。
rBFR组的CC峰值扭矩增加(p<0.05),rBFR组和对照组的IM增加(p<0.05),而rBFR组和对照组的CSA增加(p<0.001)。eBFR组运动期间的疼痛严重,rBFR组和对照组为中度。
本研究表明,rBFR高强度等速训练对增加肌肉力量和肌肉大小没有协同作用。此外,在运动期间可能最好不进行BFR高强度等速训练,因为它会引起严重疼痛并可能抑制肌肉力量的增加。