Hudak Nicholas M, Akroyd Duane
Nicholas M Hudak, PhD, MPA, MSEd, is an associate professor in the Department of Family Medicine and Community Health at Duke University School of Medicine, Durham, North Carolina.
Duane Akroyd, PhD, is a professor in the North Carolina State University, College of Education, Raleigh, North Carolina.
J Physician Assist Educ. 2024 Dec 1;35(4):346-351. doi: 10.1097/JPA.0000000000000597. Epub 2024 Jun 11.
Many physician assistant (PA) students experience mistreatment by preceptors in clinical settings though most do not report it to their institution. Nonreporting limits an institution's ability to address mistreatment and provide student support. Several reasons for nonreporting have been described in national surveys. The purpose of this study was to identify factors predictive of student reporting behavior.
This study used a nonexperimental, cross-sectional, predictive research design with quantitative analytic methods. Data were from 2 national surveys administered to PA students and programs in 2019. The sample was PA students who experienced mistreatment performed by preceptors. Logistic regression was used to identify which independent variables were predictors of student mistreatment reporting to their institution.
Students were twice as likely to report mistreatment involving physical or sexual behavior compared with other types. Older students were more likely to report mistreatment than younger students. Policy factors were not significant predictors of student reporting behavior.
Student likelihood to reporting severe forms of mistreatment indicate they recognize those behaviors as mistreatment and believe they are important enough to report. Greater likelihood of reporting by older students indicates the influence of student demographics and life experience. Policy factors and institution characteristics were not significant predictors of student reporting behavior, which suggest the limits of policy as a facilitator of mistreatment reporting. These findings have implications for educational program policy design, implementation, and evaluation, as well as underscore the need for further research to understand factors influencing students' decision to report mistreatment.
许多医师助理(PA)专业的学生在临床实习中受到带教老师的不当对待,尽管大多数人并未向所在院校报告。不报告限制了院校处理不当对待行为并为学生提供支持的能力。全国性调查中已描述了一些不报告的原因。本研究的目的是确定预测学生报告行为的因素。
本研究采用非实验性、横断面、预测性研究设计及定量分析方法。数据来自2019年对PA专业学生和项目进行的两项全国性调查。样本是经历过带教老师不当对待行为的PA专业学生。采用逻辑回归来确定哪些自变量是学生向院校报告不当对待行为的预测因素。
与其他类型的不当对待行为相比,学生报告涉及身体或性行为的不当对待行为的可能性是其他行为的两倍。年龄较大的学生比年龄较小的学生更有可能报告不当对待行为。政策因素不是学生报告行为的显著预测因素。
学生报告严重不当对待行为的可能性表明他们将这些行为视为不当对待,并认为这些行为足以重要到需要报告。年龄较大的学生报告可能性更高,这表明了学生人口统计学特征和生活经历的影响。政策因素和院校特征不是学生报告行为的显著预测因素,这表明政策在促进不当对待行为报告方面存在局限性。这些发现对教育项目的政策设计、实施和评估具有启示意义,同时也强调需要进一步开展研究,以了解影响学生决定报告不当对待行为的因素。