Nosrati Elias, Kelly Michael P, Szreter Simon
University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Br J Sociol. 2024 Dec;75(5):681-699. doi: 10.1111/1468-4446.13121. Epub 2024 Jun 15.
What are the historical conditions under which a sociologically informed understanding of health inequality can emerge in the public sphere? We seek to address this question through the lens of a strategically chosen historical puzzle-the stubborn persistence of and salient variation in high infant mortality rates across British industrial towns at the dawn of the previous century-as analysed by Arthur Newsholme, the Medical Officer of the Local Government Board. In doing so, we retrace the historical processes through which the evolving public health movement gradually helped crystallise a scientific understanding of the social causes of excess mortality. We map the dominant ideology of the public sphere at the time, chart the shifting roles of the state, and retrace the historical origins and emergence of 'public health' as a distinctive category of state policy and public discourse. We situate the public health movement in this historical configuration and identify the cracks in the existing ideological and administrative edifice through which this movement was able to articulate a novel approach to population health-one that spotlights the political economy of social inequality. We relate this historical sequence to the rise of industrial capitalism, the social fractures that it spawned, and the organised counter-movements that it necessitated.
在何种历史条件下,对健康不平等的社会学洞察能够在公共领域出现?我们试图通过一个经过策略性选择的历史谜题来回答这个问题,即上世纪初英国各工业城镇婴儿死亡率居高不下且存在显著差异,这一现象顽固持续,对此地方政府委员会医务官亚瑟·纽肖尔姆进行了分析。在此过程中,我们追溯历史进程,通过这些进程,不断发展的公共卫生运动逐渐促成了对超额死亡率社会成因的科学理解。我们描绘当时公共领域的主导意识形态,梳理国家角色的转变,追溯“公共卫生”作为一种独特的国家政策和公共话语范畴的历史起源与出现。我们将公共卫生运动置于这一历史格局中,找出现有意识形态和行政体系中的裂缝,正是通过这些裂缝,该运动得以阐明一种全新的人口健康方法,这种方法突出了社会不平等的政治经济学。我们将这一历史脉络与工业资本主义的兴起、其引发的社会裂痕以及必然出现的有组织的反运动联系起来。