Fine Rachel D, Troncoso Solangel C, Gelman Susan A
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
Br J Dev Psychol. 2025 Jun;43(2):418-439. doi: 10.1111/bjdp.12503. Epub 2024 Jun 19.
The current study explored whether positive contact through stories could influence how young children think about transgender identities and gender in general. A total of 174 children ages 5-6 and 9-10 were randomly assigned to one of three conditions: Jazz (participants watched a video regarding a transgender child named Jazz), Blue (participants watched a video regarding a marker that looked red on the outside but inside was really blue) and control (no video). Both videos described the main character as feeling different inside than outside, and their social transition to their preferred identity; researcher scaffolding supported the video messages. Children who viewed the Jazz video had: (a) greater understanding of transgender identities and (b) no overall differences in gender essentialism, but (c) lower gender essentialism on three specific measures (gender immutability, innate toy behaviours and innate preferences). Also, gender essentialism was lower in older versus younger children. In this study, a direct, realistic story was the only effective means of teaching children about transgender identities and reducing belief in gender immutability. Thus, stories can be a way to teach children about the social world and change essentialist beliefs, but the impact may be limited and greatly affected by features of the story.
当前的研究探讨了通过故事进行的积极接触是否会影响幼儿对跨性别身份和一般性别概念的思考方式。共有174名5至6岁和9至10岁的儿童被随机分配到三种条件之一:“杰斯”组(参与者观看了一段关于名为杰斯的跨性别儿童的视频)、“蓝色”组(参与者观看了一段关于一个外表看起来是红色但内部实际上是蓝色的标记物的视频)和对照组(无视频)。两段视频都将主角描述为内心感受与外在表现不同,以及他们向自己偏好的身份进行的社会转变;研究人员的引导支持了视频传达的信息。观看“杰斯”视频的儿童:(a)对跨性别身份有更深入的理解,(b)在性别本质主义方面没有总体差异,但(c)在三个具体指标(性别不变性、天生的玩具行为和天生的偏好)上的性别本质主义较低。此外,年龄较大的儿童相比年龄较小的儿童,性别本质主义更低。在本研究中,一个直接、现实的故事是教导儿童了解跨性别身份并减少对性别不变性的信念的唯一有效方式。因此,故事可以成为教导儿童了解社会世界并改变本质主义信念的一种方式,但这种影响可能有限,且会受到故事特征的极大影响。