Dane Aimee, Berkman Jennifer, DeBortoli Emily, Wallingford Courtney K, Yanes Tatiane, McInerney-Leo Aideen
Cardiology Department, Prince Charles Hospital, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
Dermatology Research Centre, Frazer Institute, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
J Genet Couns. 2025 Apr;34(2):e1938. doi: 10.1002/jgc4.1938. Epub 2024 Jun 20.
Genetic counseling facilitates psychological and social adaptation in clients and families. Two psychotherapeutic approaches, narrative and family therapy foster client adaptation to adverse situations and may enhance the genetic counseling process. This scoping review aimed to describe the applications of narrative therapy and family therapy in genetic counseling, and to document the actual and perceived value of these approaches in a genetic counseling setting. Nine original research articles and six commentary articles met the study inclusion criteria. Original articles reported on positive client attitudes when these approaches were applied to hereditary cancer and Huntington disease settings. Five studies applied either approach in group sessions, where safety was key to positive outcomes, including sharing lived experiences and coping strategies. Balanced utilization of structured and open elements in group sessions maximized a sense of control, while also allowing for opportunity to self-disclose. Narrative therapy interventions were time efficient and were reported to foster connection with others and shape a new adaptive narrative centered around strengths. Family therapy approaches, based on experiential family therapy, the intersystem model, object relations family therapy, and the social ecology model, required a greater time commitment, but promoted disclosure of complex feelings and diffused tension. Family therapy genogram tools were feasible in practice, easy to implement, and effective at identifying communication barriers. Commentary articles highlighted the alignment of both approaches with genetic counseling goals and their potential value in practice. Utilization of psychotherapeutic approaches can improve counselors' ability to shape sessions, enhance insight and optimize efficacy, and flexibility in moving between models can maximize impact. This review highlights the paucity of studies investigating the efficacy of these psychotherapeutic approaches in the genetic counseling context and the need for more outcomes-based research on the utilization of narrative or family therapy in genetic counseling practice.
遗传咨询有助于客户及其家庭在心理和社会层面进行调适。两种心理治疗方法,即叙事疗法和家庭疗法,可促进客户适应逆境,并可能增强遗传咨询过程。本范围综述旨在描述叙事疗法和家庭疗法在遗传咨询中的应用,并记录这些方法在遗传咨询环境中的实际价值和感知价值。九篇原创研究文章和六篇评论文章符合研究纳入标准。原创文章报道了将这些方法应用于遗传性癌症和亨廷顿舞蹈症背景时客户的积极态度。五项研究在小组会议中采用了其中任何一种方法,在这种情况下,安全性是取得积极成果的关键,包括分享生活经历和应对策略。在小组会议中平衡利用结构化和开放性元素可最大限度地增强控制感,同时也为自我披露提供机会。叙事疗法干预效率高,据报道能促进与他人的联系,并塑造一个围绕优势的新的适应性叙事。基于体验式家庭疗法、系统间模型、客体关系家庭疗法和社会生态模型的家庭疗法方法需要投入更多时间,但能促进复杂情感的披露并缓解紧张情绪。家庭疗法系谱图工具在实践中可行,易于实施,并且在识别沟通障碍方面有效。评论文章强调了这两种方法与遗传咨询目标的一致性及其在实践中的潜在价值。运用心理治疗方法可以提高咨询师组织咨询过程的能力,增强洞察力并优化疗效,并且在不同模型之间灵活转换可以最大化影响。本综述强调了在遗传咨询背景下研究这些心理治疗方法疗效的研究匮乏,以及需要对叙事疗法或家庭疗法在遗传咨询实践中的应用开展更多基于结果的研究。