Department of Sociology, The University of North Texas, Denton, Texas, USA.
Maxwell School of Citizenship & Public Affairs, Syracuse University, Syracuse, New York, USA.
Sociol Health Illn. 2024 Nov;46(8):1749-1771. doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.13813. Epub 2024 Jun 26.
Class-based perspectives on the persistent social gradients in health within modern welfare states largely focus on the adverse consequences of unfettered neoliberalism and entrenched meritocratic socioeconomic selection. Namely, neoliberal-driven economic inequality has fuelled resentment and stress among lower-status groups, while these groups have become more homogeneous with regard to health behaviours and outcomes. We synthesise several sociological and historical literatures to argue that, in addition to these class-based explanations, socioeconomic inequality may contribute to persistent social gradients in health due to elite class self-interest-in particular elites' preferences for overdiagnosis, overprescription and costly high-technology medical treatments over disease prevention, and for increased tolerance for regulatory capture. We demonstrate that this self-interest provides parsimonious explanations for several contemporary trends in U.S. health inequality including (A) supply-side factors in drug-related deaths, (B) longitudinal trends in the social gradients of obesity and chronic disease mortality and (C) the immigrant health advantage. We conclude that sociological theories of elite class self-interest usefully complement theories of the psychosocial effects of neoliberalism and of meritocratic social selection while answering recent calls for research on the role advantaged groups play in generating inequalities in health, and for research that moves beyond technological determinism in health sociology.
基于阶层的视角来看,现代福利国家中健康状况持续存在的社会梯度主要集中在不受约束的新自由主义和根深蒂固的精英主义社会经济选择的不利后果上。具体来说,新自由主义驱动的经济不平等加剧了低阶层群体的怨恨和压力,而这些群体在健康行为和结果方面变得更加同质化。我们综合了一些社会学和历史文献,认为除了这些基于阶层的解释之外,由于精英阶层的自利——特别是精英们对过度诊断、过度处方和昂贵的高科技医疗治疗而不是疾病预防的偏好,以及对监管俘获的容忍度增加——社会经济不平等也可能导致健康状况持续存在的社会梯度。我们证明,这种自利为美国健康不平等的几个当代趋势提供了简洁的解释,包括:(A)与药物相关的死亡中的供应方因素,(B)肥胖和慢性病死亡率的社会梯度的纵向趋势,以及(C)移民健康优势。我们的结论是,精英阶层自利的社会学理论在回答关于优势群体在健康不平等中所扮演的角色的研究呼吁以及超越健康社会学中的技术决定论的研究方面,与新自由主义的心理社会影响和精英主义社会选择理论很好地互补。