Lasco Gideon, Hardon Anita
Knowledge, Technology and Innovation Group, Wageningen University and Research, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Department of Anthropology, University of the Philippines Diliman, Diliman, Quezon City, Philippines.
Hum Organ. 2024 Jun 27;83(2):145-158. doi: 10.1080/00187259.2024.2351372. eCollection 2024.
Water quality is a major concern around the world, but assessments of quality often privilege producers, regulators and experts over consumers. With water supplies and sources constantly in flux, how do ordinary people experience and "sense" quality? How do they define "good" or "good enough" water, and what practices do they engage in to "make" good water? In this article, we attend to these questions by presenting findings from an open-ended qualitative study carried out along the Marikina River, Manila, the Philippines - a waterway that courses from rural and mountainous villages to highly urbanized communities. First, we describe the sensorial and cognitive attributes that people associate with the different water sources in their environment, as well as their decision-making regarding what kind of water to use for which purposes. Second, we present the "making" of water quality: how, in a context of polluted environments and water scarcity, do people try to secure water they consider acceptable for themselves and their families. Our findings reveal water quality as a contested, relational domain-one that reinforces social and health disparities and calls for further scholarship.
水质是全球关注的一个主要问题,但水质评估往往更偏向于生产者、监管者和专家,而非消费者。随着供水和水源不断变化,普通人如何体验和“感知”水质?他们如何定义“优质”或“足够好”的水,以及他们采取哪些做法来“制造”优质水?在本文中,我们通过展示在菲律宾马尼拉马里基纳河沿岸开展的一项开放式定性研究的结果来探讨这些问题。马里基纳河是一条从农村和山区村庄流向高度城市化社区的水道。首先,我们描述人们将其与周围不同水源相关联的感官和认知属性,以及他们对于何种用途使用何种水的决策。其次,我们呈现水质的“制造”:在环境污染和水资源稀缺的背景下,人们如何努力为自己和家人获取他们认为可接受的水。我们的研究结果揭示了水质是一个存在争议的、相互关联的领域——一个加剧社会和健康差距并需要进一步学术研究的领域。