Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute, St. Michael's Hospital, Toronto, Canada.
McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
PLoS One. 2024 Jul 11;19(7):e0305473. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0305473. eCollection 2024.
Racialized women clinicians (RWCs) experience the brunt of unfair racial and gendered expectations, which is a direct result of their visible identity. Our study sought to understand how these experiences intersect to impact the personal and professional well-being of RWCs, and their approach to diabetes care.
Data were collected from 24 RWCs working within Canadian diabetes care settings, who participated in semi-structured, one-on-one interviews conducted from April 2021 to September 2021. The data were qualitatively analyzed using thematic analysis to develop emergent themes, and interactions were explored using the socioecological model (SEM), adapted to our study context.
We identified three themes: (1) Discordance between self-identity and relational identity impacted how RWCs interacted with others, and how others interacted with them; (2) Tokenistic, "inclusive" organizational policies/practices and inherently racist and sexist social norms permitted acts of discrimination and led to the systematic othering and exclusion of RWCs within the workplace; and (3) Differential treatment of RWCs had both positive and negative impacts on participants' relational, workplace and self-identity. Using the SEM, we also found that differential treatment of RWCs stems from upstream policies, structures, and social norms, percolating through different levels of the SEM, including work environments and communities, which eventually impacts one's relational identity, as well as one's perception of oneself.
The differential treatment of RWCs arises predominantly from macro systems of the work environment. The burden to address these disparities must be shifted to the source (i.e., namely systems) by implementing interventions that equitably value diversity efforts, institute policies of accountability and correction of implicit biases, and prioritize an inclusive culture broadly across faculty and leadership.
少数族裔女性临床医生(RWCs)首当其冲地承受着不公平的种族和性别期望,这直接源于他们的可见身份。我们的研究旨在了解这些经历如何相互交织,影响 RWCs 的个人和职业健康,以及他们对糖尿病护理的方法。
数据来自 24 名在加拿大糖尿病护理环境中工作的 RWCs,他们在 2021 年 4 月至 9 月期间参加了半结构化的一对一访谈。使用主题分析对数据进行定性分析,以开发出新兴主题,并使用社会生态学模型(SEM)探索相互作用,该模型适应了我们的研究背景。
我们确定了三个主题:(1)自我认同与关系认同之间的不和谐影响了 RWCs 与他人的互动方式,以及他人与他们的互动方式;(2)象征性的、“包容”的组织政策/实践和固有的种族主义和性别歧视的社会规范允许歧视行为的发生,并导致 RWCs 在工作场所中被系统性地边缘化和排斥;(3)对 RWCs 的不同待遇对参与者的关系、工作场所和自我认同既有积极影响,也有消极影响。使用 SEM,我们还发现,对 RWCs 的不同待遇源于上游政策、结构和社会规范,通过 SEM 的不同层次(包括工作环境和社区)渗透,最终影响一个人的关系认同,以及一个人对自己的看法。
对 RWCs 的不同待遇主要源于工作环境的宏观系统。解决这些差异的负担必须通过实施公平地重视多样性努力、建立问责制和纠正隐性偏见的政策,以及在整个教师和领导层中优先考虑包容性文化的干预措施,转移到源头(即系统)。