Centre Antoine-Lacassagne, Nice, France.
Centre Bayard Orlam, Villeurbanne, France.
Cancer Radiother. 2024 Aug;28(4):323-332. doi: 10.1016/j.canrad.2024.02.003. Epub 2024 Jul 14.
The standard treatment of T2-T3 rectal adenocarcinoma is radical proctectomy by total mesorectal excision often combined with some neoadjuvant treatment. To reduce morbidity of this surgery, organ preservation strategy using various combination of radiotherapy, chemotherapy and local excision is gaining interest. Some randomized trials have proven the feasibility of such approaches. The OPERA trial demonstrated, for T2 T3<5cm diameter low-middle rectum, that a contact X-ray brachytherapy boost of 90Gy in three fractions over 4 weeks was able to achieve a planned organ preservation in 81% of patients at 3years with 97% success for tumour smaller than 3cm treated with contact X-ray brachytherapy boost first. To try to expand organ preservation to larger tumours we set up a feasibility trial in T2-T3 tumours using total neoadjuvant treatment and a contact X-ray brachytherapy boost.
The trial was approved by the institutional review board of Nice. Inclusion criteria were operable patients, 75years or less, adenocarcinoma of the low-middle rectum staged T2c-T3N0 larger than 3.5cm and less than 6cm in diameter or T2-T3N1 less than 6cm in diameter. Treatment started in all cases with neoadjuvant chemotherapy associating 5-fluoro-uracile, irinotecan and oxaliplatin ('folfirinox' regimen, four to six cycles). In case of good tumour response after four cycles, a contact X-ray brachytherapy boost (delivering 90Gy in three fractions) was given followed by chemoradiotherapy (external beam radiotherapy delivering 50Gy, with concurrent capecitabine). After six cycles if only a partial response (tumour still larger than 3cm) was seen, chemoradiotherapy was given and contact X-ray brachytherapy boost was delivered after that. At the end of this total neoadjuvant treatment a watch and wait strategy was decided in case of clinical complete response or radical proctectomy by total mesorectal excision for partial response.
Between July 2019 and October 2022, 14 patients were included; median age was 66years (range: 51-77years), there were nine male and five female, two T2 N1 tumours, seven T3N0, and five T3N1, all were M0. Median tumour diameter was 40mm (range: 11-50mm); three tumours had a circumferential extension greater than 50%. Seven patients received four folfirinox cycles and seven had six cycles. Contact X-ray brachytherapy boost was given during folfirinox chemotherapy before chemoradiotherapy in 11 patients (and after in three). The tolerance was good, with no grade 4-5 toxicity. The main grade 3 early toxicity was in relation with the folfirinox regimen. A clinical complete response was seen in 12 patients at the end of the total neoadjuvant treatment (85%). All these patients are alive and have preserved their rectum with a mean follow-up time of 17.8months (range: 6-48months) and a good bowel function (low anterior rectal resection syndrome score below 30). The main contact X-ray brachytherapy boost toxicity was radiation ulceration in three patients that usually healed within 6 months, sometimes necessitating hyperbaric oxygen.
The preliminary results of this feasibility study show that early tolerance of these intensive total neoadjuvant treatment is compatible with an acceptable toxicity. The high rate of organ preservation in this intermediate group of T2-T3 tumours is encouraging and is a good argument to start the next randomized TRESOR trial that will aim at achieving a 65% of 3-year survival with organ preservation in this intermediate tumour group.
T2-T3 直肠腺癌的标准治疗方法是通过全直肠系膜切除术进行根治性直肠切除术,通常结合一些新辅助治疗。为了降低这种手术的发病率,使用各种放疗、化疗和局部切除相结合的器官保留策略越来越受到关注。一些随机试验已经证明了这些方法的可行性。OPERA 试验证明,对于 T2-T3<5cm 直径的中下段直肠,在四周内分三次给予 90Gy 的接触式 X 射线近距离放疗增敏剂,在 3 年内,81%的患者能够实现器官保留,对于直径小于 3cm 的肿瘤,97%的成功率用接触式 X 射线近距离放疗增敏剂治疗。为了尝试将器官保留扩大到更大的肿瘤,我们在 T2-T3 肿瘤中进行了一项可行性试验,使用全新辅助治疗和接触式 X 射线近距离放疗增敏剂。
该试验得到尼斯机构审查委员会的批准。纳入标准为可手术患者,年龄 75 岁以下,中下段直肠腺癌,T2c-T3N0 期肿瘤直径大于 3.5cm 且小于 6cm,或 T2-T3N1 期肿瘤直径小于 6cm。所有患者均开始接受新辅助化疗,联合氟尿嘧啶、伊立替康和奥沙利铂(“FOLFIRINOX”方案,四至六周期)。如果在四个周期后肿瘤反应良好,给予接触式 X 射线近距离放疗增敏剂(分三次给予 90Gy),然后进行放化疗(外照射放疗 50Gy,同时给予卡培他滨)。如果在六个周期后仅观察到部分反应(肿瘤仍大于 3cm),则给予放化疗,并在其后给予接触式 X 射线近距离放疗增敏剂。在完成全新辅助治疗后,如果临床完全缓解,或在部分缓解的情况下进行全直肠系膜切除术,决定进行观察等待策略。
2019 年 7 月至 2022 年 10 月,共纳入 14 例患者;中位年龄为 66 岁(范围:51-77 岁),男性 9 例,女性 5 例,T2N1 期肿瘤 2 例,T3N0 期肿瘤 7 例,T3N1 期肿瘤 5 例,均为 M0 期。肿瘤直径中位数为 40mm(范围:11-50mm);3 例肿瘤环周扩展大于 50%。7 例患者接受了四个 FOLFIRINOX 周期,7 例患者接受了六个周期。在 11 例患者中,在接受放化疗前(3 例患者在接受放化疗后)给予接触式 X 射线近距离放疗增敏剂;耐受性良好,无 4-5 级毒性。主要的 3 级早期毒性与 FOLFIRINOX 方案有关。12 例患者在全新辅助治疗结束时出现临床完全缓解(85%)。所有这些患者都存活并保留了直肠,中位随访时间为 17.8 个月(范围:6-48 个月),且具有良好的肠道功能(低位前切除综合征评分低于 30)。主要的接触式 X 射线近距离放疗增敏剂毒性是辐射溃疡,在 3 例患者中出现,通常在 6 个月内愈合,有时需要高压氧治疗。
这项可行性研究的初步结果表明,这些强化全新辅助治疗的早期耐受性与可接受的毒性相兼容。在 T2-T3 肿瘤的这一中间组中,高比例的器官保留令人鼓舞,这是一个很好的论据,可以启动下一项 TRESOR 随机试验,该试验旨在实现 65%的 3 年生存率,同时在这一中间肿瘤组中保留器官。