Toronto Rehabilitation Institute, University Health Network, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
KITE Research Institute, Toronto Rehabilitation Institute, University Health Network, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2024 Sep;25(9):105148. doi: 10.1016/j.jamda.2024.105148. Epub 2024 Jul 14.
Due to the rise of the nurse practitioner (NP) role in long-term care settings, it is important to understand the underlying structures and processes that influence NP and physician care models. This scoping review aims to answer the question, "What are the structures, processes, and outcomes of care models involving NPs and physicians in long-term care (LTC) homes?" A secondary aim was to describe the structural enablers and barriers across care models.
Seven databases were searched. Studies that described NPs and physicians working in LTC were identified and included in the review. We stratified the findings by care model and synthesized using the Donabedian model, which evaluates health care quality based on 3 dimensions: structure, process, and outcome. We then categorized macro, meso, and micro structural enablers and barriers.
Sixty papers were included in the review. The main structural influencers within 5 care models included policies on scope of practice, clarity of role description, and workload. A limited number of papers referred to the process of enabling the development of a working relationship. Thirty-five (49%) studies described resident, staff, and health system outcomes.
Although structural characteristics of NP and physician care models are described in-depth, there is less detail on the processes that occur within the NP and physician care models. We highlight structural barriers and enablers within the care models, allowing for recognition of the importance of organizational influence on the NP and physician relationship. Future work should focus on the processes of the relationships in the models by identifying the drivers and initiators of collaboration between NPs and physicians and how these relationships influence outcomes.
由于长期护理环境中护士从业者(NP)角色的兴起,了解影响 NP 和医师护理模式的基础结构和流程非常重要。本范围综述旨在回答以下问题:“涉及长期护理(LTC)院中的 NP 和医师的护理模式的结构、流程和结果是什么?” 次要目的是描述护理模式的结构促进因素和障碍。
搜索了 7 个数据库。确定并纳入了描述 NP 和医师在 LTC 中工作的研究。我们根据护理模式对研究结果进行分层,并使用 Donabedian 模型进行综合评估,该模型根据结构、过程和结果三个维度评估医疗保健质量。然后,我们对宏观、中观和微观结构的促进因素和障碍进行分类。
综述共纳入 60 篇论文。5 种护理模式中的主要结构影响因素包括实践范围政策、角色描述的明确性和工作量。很少有论文提到促进建立工作关系的过程。35 项(49%)研究描述了居民、员工和卫生系统的结果。
尽管深入描述了 NP 和医师护理模式的结构特征,但对护理模式内发生的过程的描述较少。我们强调了护理模式中的结构障碍和促进因素,从而认识到组织对 NP 和医师关系的影响的重要性。未来的工作应侧重于模型中关系的过程,确定 NP 和医师之间合作的驱动因素和启动因素,以及这些关系如何影响结果。