Nikpasand Maryam, Middendorf Jill M, Ella Vincent A, Jones Kristen E, Ladd Bryan, Takahashi Takashi, Barocas Victor H, Ellingson Arin M
Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Minnesota Minneapolis Minnesota USA.
Department of Mechanical Engineering Johns Hopkins University Baltimore Maryland USA.
JOR Spine. 2024 Jul 15;7(3):e1353. doi: 10.1002/jsp2.1353. eCollection 2024 Sep.
Degeneration of both intervertebral discs (IVDs) and facet joints in the lumbar spine has been associated with low back pain, but whether and how IVD/joint degeneration contributes to pain remains an open question. Joint degeneration can be identified by pairing T1 and T2 magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with analysis techniques such as Pfirrmann grades (IVD degeneration) and Fujiwara scores (facet degeneration). However, these grades are subjective, prompting the need to develop an automated technique to enhance inter-rater reliability. This study introduces an automated convolutional neural network (CNN) technique trained on clinical MRI images of IVD and facet joints obtained from public-access Lumbar Spine MRI Dataset. The primary goal of the automated system is to classify health of lumbar discs and facet joints according to Pfirrmann and Fujiwara grading systems and to enhance inter-rater reliability associated with these grading systems.
Performance of the CNN on both the Pfirrmann and Fujiwara scales was measured by comparing the percent agreement, Pearson's correlation and Fleiss kappa value for results from the classifier to the grades assigned by an expert grader.
The CNN demonstrates comparable performance to human graders for both Pfirrmann and Fujiwara grading systems, but with larger errors in Fujiwara grading. The CNN improves the reliability of the Pfirrmann system, aligning with previous findings for IVD assessment.
The study highlights the potential of using deep learning in classifying the IVD and facet joint health, and due to the high variability in the Fujiwara scoring system, highlights the need for improved imaging and scoring techniques to evaluate facet joint health. All codes required to use the automatic grading routines described herein are available in the Data Repository for University of Minnesota (DRUM).
腰椎间盘(IVD)和小关节退变均与腰痛相关,但IVD/关节退变是否以及如何导致疼痛仍是一个悬而未决的问题。关节退变可通过将T1和T2磁共振成像(MRI)与诸如Pfirrmann分级(IVD退变)和藤原评分(小关节退变)等分析技术相结合来识别。然而,这些分级是主观的,这促使人们需要开发一种自动化技术来提高评分者间的可靠性。本研究介绍了一种在从公共访问的腰椎MRI数据集中获取的IVD和小关节临床MRI图像上训练的自动化卷积神经网络(CNN)技术。该自动化系统的主要目标是根据Pfirrmann和藤原分级系统对腰椎间盘和小关节的健康状况进行分类,并提高与这些分级系统相关的评分者间可靠性。
通过比较分类器结果与专家评分者给出的分级之间的一致性百分比、Pearson相关性和Fleiss卡方值,来衡量CNN在Pfirrmann和藤原量表上的性能。
对于Pfirrmann和藤原分级系统,CNN表现出与人类评分者相当的性能,但在藤原分级中存在较大误差。CNN提高了Pfirrmann系统的可靠性,这与先前关于IVD评估的研究结果一致。
该研究突出了使用深度学习对IVD和小关节健康状况进行分类的潜力,并且由于藤原评分系统的高度变异性,突出了改进成像和评分技术以评估小关节健康状况的必要性。使用本文所述自动分级程序所需的所有代码均可在明尼苏达大学数据存储库(DRUM)中获取。