Habte Meseret Firde, Tegegne Biresaw Ayen, Alemayehu Tikuneh Yetneberk
College of Health Sciences, Debre Tabor University, Debre Tabor, Ethiopia.
College of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Gondar, Gondar, Ethiopia.
PLoS One. 2024 Jul 17;19(7):e0306933. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0306933. eCollection 2024.
Surgical Patients and hospitals are now facing financial strain due to direct anesthetic demand as a result of the development of new anesthetic drugs, equipment, and techniques. Up to 15% of a hospital's pharmacy budget is currently allocated to anesthetic drug expenses. Drug wastage during anesthesia practice is a widespread hidden source of healthcare waste that leads to anesthetic drug shortages as well as poor operating room efficiency. On the other hand, despite the fact that it is preventable in the vast majority of cases, it is well described that drug wastage is routinely observed, including in developing countries where the consequences significantly affect both hospitals and patients.
This review aims to review the prevalence of anesthetic drug waste across the world and systematically formulate and describe preventive strategies. Relevant publications were identified using systematic searches on databases including Google Scholar, Medline (PubMed), the Cochrane Library, and Embase. In addition, papers were detected and then selected through the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) criteria guidelines and the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Using the predetermined terms and dates from the searching databases, a total of 504 articles were identified. Based on the screening criteria, 16 papers were considered eligible and included in the final review. In addition, the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Manual for Evidence Synthesis was used for evaluating the quality of selected articles. This study is registered on PROSPERO, number CRD42024497044.
Of the sixteen publications from eleven different nations that were considered suitable for inclusion, only two of them addressed the waste of inhalational anesthetics. In more than half of eligible articles, propofol was the frequently wasted drug that contributed to increased financial loss through drug waste. The first most significant factor contributing to the waste of intravenous and inhalational anesthetics was the disposal of multidrug vials following their use for a single patient and high fresh gas flow, respectively.
Anesthetic medication waste is a common occurrence worldwide, despite the fact that it is expensive and has a significant negative impact on operating room efficiency. Because the majority of drug waste is avoidable, preventive measures may lower drug waste and improve patient and hospital efficiency.
由于新型麻醉药物、设备和技术的发展,手术患者和医院目前因直接的麻醉需求而面临财务压力。目前,医院药房预算的高达15%用于麻醉药物费用。麻醉实践中的药物浪费是医疗保健浪费的一个普遍存在的隐藏来源,导致麻醉药物短缺以及手术室效率低下。另一方面,尽管在绝大多数情况下药物浪费是可以预防的,但众所周知,药物浪费经常被观察到,包括在发展中国家,其后果对医院和患者都有重大影响。
本综述旨在回顾全球麻醉药物浪费的流行情况,并系统地制定和描述预防策略。通过在谷歌学术、Medline(PubMed)、Cochrane图书馆和Embase等数据库上进行系统检索来识别相关出版物。此外,通过系统评价和Meta分析的首选报告项目(PRISMA)标准指南以及纳入和排除标准来检测并选择论文。使用从检索数据库中预先确定的术语和日期,共识别出了504篇文章。根据筛选标准,16篇论文被认为符合要求并纳入最终综述。此外,使用乔安娜·布里格斯研究所(JBI)证据综合手册来评估所选文章的质量。本研究已在PROSPERO上注册,编号为CRD42024497044。
在被认为适合纳入的来自11个不同国家的16篇出版物中,只有两篇涉及吸入麻醉药的浪费。在超过一半的符合条件的文章中,丙泊酚是经常被浪费的药物,通过药物浪费导致了财务损失的增加。导致静脉麻醉药和吸入麻醉药浪费的第一个最重要因素分别是在单一患者使用后丢弃多剂量药瓶和高新鲜气体流量。
尽管麻醉药物浪费成本高昂且对手术室效率有重大负面影响,但在全球范围内却是普遍现象。由于大多数药物浪费是可以避免的,预防措施可能会减少药物浪费并提高患者和医院的效率。