Ubisse Capitine Igor P, Manhiça Álvaro Marcela, Tembe Júnior Paulo, Ramgi Patrícia M, Chicumbe Sérgio, Kroidl Arne, Fischer Martin R, De Schacht Caroline
Instituto Nacional de Saúde (INS), Maputo Province, Mozambique.
Centre for International Health (CIH), LMU Munich, Munich, Germany.
Vaccine X. 2024 Jun 6;19:100510. doi: 10.1016/j.jvacx.2024.100510. eCollection 2024 Aug.
This study recognized the lack of information regarding recruitment and retention factors associated with implementing HIV vaccine trials from the perspective of participants. It aimed to describe the motives and experiences of 31 young adults who participated in a phase II HIV vaccine clinical trial conducted in Maputo, Mozambique.
This was an ancillary study with a mixed-method approach that employed a convergent design, combining both quantitative and qualitative methodologies. Data collection involved questionnaire surveys, in-depth interviews, and focus group discussions. Participants were assessed before and after learning whether they received the experimental vaccine or placebo. Thematic analysis was used for qualitative data, while descriptive analysis and statistical tests such as Fischer's test and McNemar's exact test were applied to quantitative data. The study also utilized the Health Belief Model to understand the decision-making process of participating in an HIV vaccine study.
Most of our participants were young females, single, with limited financial resources. Participants joined the trial with the belief that they had a unique opportunity to help the fight against HIV and contribute to the research for the discovery of an HIV vaccine. Positive experiences related to trial participation include gaining knowledge about HIV and personal health and receiving risk reduction counseling. Participants reported blood collection as a negative experience and that they suffered social harm because of trial participation. Participants felt abandoned after the trial ended.
Preventive HIV vaccine trials should integrate a social-behavioral component to assess reasons for participation and refusal in real-time. Providing ongoing personal attention is crucial for young individuals who have committed 1-2 years to trial participation, extending beyond the trial period. Implementing tailored strategies for HIV risk assessment and reduction during and after the trial is essential. Addressing these factors can enhance preventive HIV vaccine trial implementation.
本研究认识到,从参与者的角度来看,缺乏与开展HIV疫苗试验相关的招募和留存因素方面的信息。其目的是描述31名参与在莫桑比克马普托进行的II期HIV疫苗临床试验的年轻人的动机和经历。
这是一项采用混合方法的辅助研究,采用收敛设计,结合定量和定性方法。数据收集包括问卷调查、深入访谈和焦点小组讨论。在参与者得知自己接受的是实验性疫苗还是安慰剂之前和之后对他们进行评估。定性数据采用主题分析,定量数据则应用描述性分析和统计检验,如费舍尔检验和麦克尼马尔精确检验。该研究还利用健康信念模型来理解参与HIV疫苗研究的决策过程。
我们的大多数参与者是年轻女性,单身,经济资源有限。参与者参与试验是相信自己有独特机会助力抗击HIV,并为发现HIV疫苗的研究做出贡献。与参与试验相关的积极经历包括获得有关HIV和个人健康的知识以及接受降低风险咨询。参与者将采血视为负面经历,并表示因参与试验而遭受社会伤害。试验结束后,参与者感到被遗弃。
预防性HIV疫苗试验应纳入社会行为成分,以实时评估参与和拒绝的原因。对于那些投入1至2年参与试验的年轻人,在试验期之后继续给予个人关注至关重要。在试验期间和之后实施针对性的HIV风险评估和降低策略至关重要。解决这些因素可加强预防性HIV疫苗试验的开展。