Lehigh Valley Health Network, University of South Florida Morsani College of Medicine, Department of Emergency and Hospital Medicine, Allentown, Pennsylvania.
West J Emerg Med. 2024 Jul;25(4):565-573. doi: 10.5811/westjem.18082.
Evidence-based medicine (EBM) is a critical skill for physicians, and EBM competency has been shown to increase implementation of best medical practices, reduce medical errors, and increase patient-centered care. Like any skill, EBM must be practiced, receiving iterative feedback to improve learners' comprehension. Having residents document patient interactions in logbooks to allow for residency program review, feedback, and documentation of competency has been previously described as a best practice within emergency medicine (EM) to document practice-based learning (PBL) competency. Quantifying how residents use the information they query, locate, evaluate, and apply while providing direct patient care can measure the efficacy of EBM education and provide insight into more efficient ways of providing medical care.
Practice-based learning logs were surveys created to record resident EBM activity on-shift and were placed into our residency management software program. Residents were required to submit 3-5 surveys of EBM activity performed during a 28-day rotation during which additional information was sought. This study included all PBL logs completed by EM residents from June 1, 2013-May 11, 2020. Using qualitative methodology, a codebook was created to analyze residents' free-text responses to the prompt: "Based on your research, would you have done anything differently?" The codebook was designed to generate a three-digit code conveying the effect of the researched information on the patient about whom the log was written, as well as whether the information would affect future patient care and whether these decisions were based on scientific evidence.
A total of 10,574 logs were included for primary analysis. In total, 1,977 (18.7%) logs indicated that the evidence acquired through research would affect future patient care. Of these, 392 (3.7%) explicitly stated that the EBM activity conducted as part of our project led to real-time changes in patient care in the ED and would change future management of patients as well.
We present a proof of concept that PBL log activity can lead to integration of evidence-based medicine into real-time patient care. While a convenience sample, our cohort recorded evidence of both lifelong learning and application to patient care.
循证医学(EBM)是医生的一项关键技能,已证明 EBM 能力的提高可以促进最佳医疗实践的实施,减少医疗错误,并增加以患者为中心的护理。像任何技能一样,EBM 必须通过实践来提高学习者的理解能力,并获得迭代反馈。让住院医师在日志中记录患者的互动情况,以便对住院医师计划进行审查、提供反馈并记录能力,这在急诊医学(EM)中已经被描述为记录基于实践的学习(PBL)能力的最佳实践。量化住院医师在提供直接患者护理时如何使用他们查询、定位、评估和应用的信息,可以衡量 EBM 教育的效果,并深入了解更有效的医疗保健提供方式。
基于实践的学习日志是为记录住院医师轮班时的 EBM 活动而创建的调查,并将其放入我们的住院医师管理软件程序中。要求住院医师在 28 天的轮班期间提交 3-5 份完成的 EBM 活动调查,在此期间会寻求其他信息。本研究包括 2013 年 6 月 1 日至 2020 年 5 月 11 日期间 EM 住院医师完成的所有 PBL 日志。使用定性方法,创建了一个代码本,以分析住院医师对提示的自由文本回答:“根据你的研究,你会有什么不同的做法吗?”代码本旨在生成一个三位数的代码,传达研究信息对所写日志患者的影响,以及这些信息是否会影响未来的患者护理,以及这些决策是否基于科学证据。
共有 10574 份日志被纳入主要分析。总的来说,1977 份(18.7%)日志表明,通过研究获得的证据将影响未来的患者护理。在这些日志中,有 392 份(3.7%)明确表示,作为我们项目的一部分进行的 EBM 活动导致了 ED 中实时的患者护理变化,并将改变未来患者的管理。
我们提出了一个概念验证,即 PBL 日志活动可以将循证医学融入实时患者护理。虽然是一个方便样本,但我们的队列记录了终身学习和应用于患者护理的证据。