Oral Health Prev Dent. 2024 Jul 23;22:317-326. doi: 10.3290/j.ohpd.b5574011.
To examine the anti-caries effect of mouthwashes containing Cibotium barometz J. Smith (CB), a natural substance, and compare it with chlorhexidine and saline solution.
A randomised, blinded clinical trial was conducted on 76 study participants. The differences between the 3 gargle groups (saline gargle: SAL; chlorhexidine gargle: CHX; CB gargle group: CB) and the differences over time (baseline, after 1 week, after 2 weeks) were compared. To this end, ANOVA was performed on caries-related clinical indicators (e.g. O'Leary plaque index, caries activity, and satisfaction).
The O'Leary index, caries activity, and saliva tests, gradually improved in group CB at one and two weeks. In the case of bacterial tests, unlike SAL and CHX, only in group CB did the decrease occur one and two weeks later. The caries-related indicators decreased significantly over time in group CB compared to SAL and CHX groups, and there was also a statistically significant difference in interaction between groups and time (p<0.05).
The mouthwash containing CB extract showed statistically significant improvement in biofilm adhesion as well as the saliva and bacterial tests compared to SAL and CHX. However, since there were differences in the initial oral conditions of the three groups, additional long-term research is needed through crossover clinical trials to supplement these.
研究含天然物质金毛狗脊(CB)的漱口水的抗龋效果,并将其与洗必泰、生理盐水进行比较。
对 76 名研究参与者进行了一项随机、双盲的临床试验。比较了 3 个含漱组(生理盐水含漱:SAL;洗必泰含漱:CHX;CB 含漱组:CB)之间的差异以及随时间的变化(基线、1 周后、2 周后)。为此,对与龋病相关的临床指标(如 O'Leary 菌斑指数、龋病活性和满意度)进行了方差分析。
在第 1 周和第 2 周,CB 组的 O'Leary 指数、龋病活性和唾液测试逐渐改善。在细菌测试方面,与 SAL 和 CHX 不同,仅在 CB 组,1 周和 2 周后才出现下降。与 SAL 和 CHX 组相比,CB 组的龋病相关指标随时间显著下降,且组间和时间间的交互作用也存在统计学差异(p<0.05)。
与 SAL 和 CHX 相比,含 CB 提取物的漱口水在生物膜黏附以及唾液和细菌测试方面均显示出统计学上的显著改善。然而,由于三组的初始口腔状况存在差异,需要通过交叉临床试验进行额外的长期研究来补充这些结果。