Alkhatib Maram, Hasan Inaya, Ali Ayra, Zaidi Zareen
Acad Med. 2024 Nov 1;99(11):1199-1207. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000005822. Epub 2024 Jul 23.
The Arab experience is understudied because until 2024 Arabs were categorized as White on the U.S. Census, leading to diminished documentation of their personal experiences. There is also little understanding of the Arab experience and its intersectionality with gender, being an international medical graduate (IMG), and working in academia. The authors studied the experience of Arab women IMGs working in the U.S. academic system.
This qualitative study used interpretative phenomenological analysis to analyze in-depth interview data from 20 first-generation U.S. immigrant Arab women who were IMGs. Interpretative phenomenologicalanalysis involved data familiarization, immersion, and coding. Codes were grouped into potential themes on the participants' experience. The authors explored connections between the themes and engaged in reflexive practice through memo writing and team meetings. The study was performed from November 2022-May 2023.
The experiences of the 20 first-generation U.S. immigrant Arab women IMGs were as diverse as the Arab identity itself but congruent with some documented IMG experiences. Political turmoil, desire for new opportunities, and career goals were all reasons that led them to emigrate, but cultural differences, isolation from their home countries, and missing family were central to their experiences. Muslim women wearing the hijab or those with heavy accents faced more microaggressions and xenophobia in academic clinical settings. Those in environments that embraced their differences and supported them described less discrimination. They all felt, nonetheless, that they benefited from training in the United States. However, they noted room for improving cultural humility in residencies and the need for a more inclusive workplace.
This study highlights the visible and invisible challenges that affect Arab women IMGs' experience in the United States. Program directors and department leaders should try to learn about the backgrounds of IMGs and current geopolitical events that might affect IMGs and extend support.
阿拉伯人的经历尚未得到充分研究,因为直到2024年,在美国人口普查中阿拉伯人都被归类为白人,这导致他们个人经历的记录减少。人们对阿拉伯人的经历以及它与性别、作为国际医学毕业生(IMG)以及在学术界工作的交叉性也知之甚少。作者研究了在美国学术系统中工作的阿拉伯女性国际医学毕业生的经历。
这项定性研究采用解释现象学分析方法,对20名第一代美国移民阿拉伯女性国际医学毕业生的深度访谈数据进行分析。解释现象学分析包括数据熟悉、沉浸和编码。代码被分组为关于参与者经历的潜在主题。作者探索了这些主题之间的联系,并通过写备忘录和团队会议进行反思性实践。该研究于2022年11月至2023年5月进行。
20名第一代美国移民阿拉伯女性国际医学毕业生的经历与阿拉伯身份本身一样多样,但与一些已记录的国际医学毕业生经历一致。政治动荡、对新机会的渴望和职业目标都是导致她们移民的原因,但文化差异、与祖国隔绝和思念家人是她们经历的核心。戴头巾的穆斯林女性或口音较重的女性在学术临床环境中面临更多的微侵犯和仇外心理。那些处于接纳她们差异并给予支持的环境中的人所描述的歧视较少。尽管如此,她们都觉得自己从在美国的培训中受益。然而,她们指出住院医师培训中在文化谦逊方面仍有改进空间,并且需要一个更具包容性的工作场所。
本研究突出了影响阿拉伯女性国际医学毕业生在美国经历的可见和不可见挑战。项目主任和部门领导应该努力了解国际医学毕业生的背景以及可能影响国际医学毕业生的当前地缘政治事件,并给予支持。