College of Technology and Design, University of Economics Ho Chi Minh City, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.
PLoS One. 2024 Jul 26;19(7):e0307894. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0307894. eCollection 2024.
The quest for sustainable energy solutions has intensified interest in marine renewables, particularly wave energy. This study addresses the crucial need for an objective assessment of Wave Energy Converter (WEC) technologies, which are instrumental in harnessing ocean waves for electricity generation. To benchmark WEC technologies, we employed an integrated approach combining the MEthod based on the Removal Effects of Criteria (MEREC) and the Spherical Fuzzy Combine Compromise Solution (SF-CoCoSo). MEREC provided a systematic way to determine the importance of various benchmarking criteria, while SF-CoCoSo facilitated the synthesis of complex decision-making data into a coherent evaluation score for each technology. The results of the study offer a definitive ranking of WEC technologies, with findings emphasizing the importance of grid connectivity and adaptability to various wave conditions as pivotal to the technologies' success. While the study makes significant strides in the evaluation of WECs, it also recognizes limitations, including the potential for evolving market dynamics to influence criteria weightings and the assumption that the MCDM methods capture all decision-making complexities. Future work should expand the evaluative criteria and explore additional MCDM methods to validate and refine the benchmarking process further.
对可持续能源解决方案的探索促使人们对海洋可再生能源,特别是波浪能产生了浓厚的兴趣。本研究针对波浪能转换器(WEC)技术的客观评估这一关键需求,这些技术对于利用海洋波浪发电至关重要。为了对 WEC 技术进行基准测试,我们采用了一种结合基于标准消除效应的方法(MEREC)和球形模糊综合妥协解(SF-CoCoSo)的综合方法。MEREC 为确定各种基准测试标准的重要性提供了一种系统的方法,而 SF-CoCoSo 则便于将复杂的决策数据综合成每个技术的一致评估得分。研究结果提供了 WEC 技术的明确排名,研究结果强调了电网连接和适应各种波浪条件的能力的重要性,这些是技术成功的关键。虽然该研究在 WEC 的评估方面取得了重大进展,但它也认识到了一些局限性,包括市场动态变化可能影响标准权重的可能性,以及假设 MCDM 方法可以捕捉所有决策复杂性的可能性。未来的工作应该扩展评估标准,并探索其他 MCDM 方法,以进一步验证和完善基准测试过程。