Department of Pathology, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS B3H 1X5, Canada.
Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS B3H 1X5, Canada.
Biomolecules. 2024 Jul 19;14(7):866. doi: 10.3390/biom14070866.
Calreticulin (CRT) is an intrinsically disordered multifunctional protein that plays essential roles intra-and extra-cellularly. The Michalak laboratory has proposed that CRT was initially identified in 1974 by the MacLennan laboratory as the high-affinity Ca-binding protein (HACBP) of the sarcoplasmic reticulin (SR). This widely accepted belief has been ingrained in the scientific literature but has never been rigorously tested. In our report, we have undertaken a comprehensive reexamination of this assumption by meticulously examining the majority of published studies that present a proteomic analysis of the SR. These analyses have utilized proteomic analysis of purified SR preparations or purified components of the SR, namely the longitudinal tubules and junctional terminal cisternae. These studies have consistently failed to detect the HACBP or CRT in skeletal muscle SR. We propose that the existence of the HACBP has failed the test of reproducibility and should be retired to the annals of antiquity. Therefore, the scientific dogma that the HACBP and CRT are identical proteins is a non sequitur.
钙网蛋白(CRT)是一种无规则的多功能蛋白,在细胞内外发挥着重要作用。Michalak 实验室提出,CRT 最初是在 1974 年被 MacLennan 实验室作为肌浆网(SR)的高亲和力 Ca 结合蛋白(HACBP)鉴定出来的。这一被广泛接受的观点已经在科学文献中根深蒂固,但从未经过严格的测试。在我们的报告中,我们通过仔细检查大多数发表的研究来全面重新检验这一假设,这些研究对 SR 的蛋白质组学分析进行了分析。这些分析利用了对纯化的 SR 制剂或 SR 的纯化成分(即长管和连接终端池)的蛋白质组学分析。这些研究一致未能在骨骼肌 SR 中检测到 HACBP 或 CRT。我们提出,HACBP 的存在未能通过可重复性测试,应归入古代。因此,HACBP 和 CRT 是相同蛋白的科学教条是不合逻辑的。