Storck Katharina, Eufinger Julia, Kotz Sebastian, Classen Carolina, Ritschl Lucas M
Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Klinikum Rechts der Isar, School of Medicine and Health, Technical University Munich, 81675 Munich, Germany.
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, School of Medicine, University of Saarland, Homburg/Saar, 66421 Homburg, Germany.
Life (Basel). 2024 Jun 27;14(7):813. doi: 10.3390/life14070813.
The integration of three-dimensional (3D) cameras into clinical practice for pre-operative planning and post-operative monitoring of rhinoplasties remains controversial. However, this technology offers the advantage of capturing the 3D surface without exposing patients to potentially harmful radiation. Continuous assessment allows the follow-up of swelling patterns, cartilage alignment, and bone remodeling. The primary objective of our study was to quantify changes in nasal structure before and after rhinoplasty by using 3D photography. Our study cohort consisted of 29 patients who underwent open structural rhinoplasty. We used the Artec Space Spider camera to acquire a total of 103 3D images. We collected pre-operative and at least two or three post-operative follow-up scans, which were taken one, three, and six months after surgery. We evaluated paired scans that included various time intervals to improve our understanding of swelling behavior and to ensure an objective analysis of changes. Eleven specific anatomical landmarks were identified for measurement. Two independent raters determined the distances between these landmarks over time. The calculation of intraclass correlation coefficients showed low inter-rater variability. Statistically significant changes over time ( < 0.05) were observed for various anatomical landmarks, including soft tissue nasion, soft tissue orbitale right, soft tissue maxillofrontale left, soft tissue maxillofrontale right, nasal bridge, and nasal break point. Conversely, no significant changes ( > 0.05) were observed in the measurements of soft tissue orbitale left, pronasale, subnasale, alare right, or alare left. A visual assessment was conducted using surface distance maps. The results indicate that the complete decrease in swelling takes at least 6 months or even longer. Additionally, 3D photography can provide an objectively comparable analysis of the face and external contours. Furthermore, it allows for a comparison of external contours and therefore pre- and post-operative differences.
将三维(3D)相机整合到鼻整形术前规划和术后监测的临床实践中仍存在争议。然而,这项技术具有在不使患者暴露于潜在有害辐射的情况下捕捉3D表面的优势。持续评估能够跟踪肿胀模式、软骨排列和骨重塑情况。我们研究的主要目的是通过使用3D摄影来量化鼻整形术前和术后鼻结构的变化。我们的研究队列由29例行开放式结构性鼻整形术的患者组成。我们使用Artec Space Spider相机共获取了103张3D图像。我们收集了术前以及术后至少两到三次随访扫描图像,这些图像在术后1个月、3个月和6个月拍摄。我们评估了包括不同时间间隔的配对扫描图像,以增进我们对肿胀行为的理解并确保对变化进行客观分析。确定了11个特定的解剖标志点进行测量。两名独立的评估者确定这些标志点随时间的距离。组内相关系数的计算显示评估者间变异性较低。观察到包括软组织鼻根点、右侧软组织眶下点、左侧软组织上颌额突点、右侧软组织上颌额突点、鼻梁和鼻断点在内的各种解剖标志点随时间有统计学显著变化(<0.05)。相反,在左侧软组织眶下点、鼻尖点、鼻下点、右侧鼻翼点或左侧鼻翼点的测量中未观察到显著变化(>0.05)。使用表面距离图进行了视觉评估。结果表明肿胀完全消退至少需要6个月甚至更长时间。此外,3D摄影可以对面部和外部轮廓进行客观可比的分析。此外,它还允许对外部轮廓进行比较,从而比较术前和术后的差异。