Wenig Katharina, Pacher Lisa, Bugnyar Thomas
Department of Behavioural and Cognitive Biology, University of Vienna, Austria.
Haidlhof Research Station, University of Vienna and University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Bad Vöslau, Austria.
Anim Behav. 2022 Feb;184:71-80. doi: 10.1016/j.anbehav.2021.12.009.
Emotional contagion refers to the mechanism of aligning with conspecifics' emotional states and is thought to be highly beneficial in social group living. While emotional contagion is well studied in humans, most studies in nonhuman animals fail to clearly distinguish between behavioural and emotional contagion. Furthermore, evidence for positive emotional contagion in nonhuman animals is almost entirely restricted to the context of play. In the present study, we aimed at adding observational evidence of contagion in a positive context, while separating aspects of behavioural and emotional contagion. In a group of nonbreeder common ravens, , we investigated whether witnessing conspecifics in positive social interaction, namely allopreening, would influence a bystander's behavioural and, possibly, emotional state. We recorded behavioural expressions of bystanders in postpreening observation phases and compared them to those in matched-control observation phases. We found effects of witnessing others' allopreening on the bystanders' subsequent affiliative interactions but not on their self-directed behaviours (e.g. autopreening) or agonistic interactions. Specifically, bystanders were more likely to engage in allopreening themselves in the postpreening observation phase than in the matched-control observation phase, which could be explained via behavioural and emotional contagion; however, bystanders also showed elevated levels of nonpreening affiliative interactions and spent more time close to conspecifics after observing others allopreening, which hints towards a more general effect on the bystanders' emotional states. Whether these nonpreening affiliative interactions are indeed an indication of emotional contagion needs to be tested in further studies that measure, and manipulate, emotional states.
情绪感染是指与同种个体的情绪状态保持一致的机制,被认为在社会群体生活中非常有益。虽然人类的情绪感染已得到充分研究,但大多数针对非人类动物的研究未能明确区分行为感染和情绪感染。此外,非人类动物中积极情绪感染的证据几乎完全局限于玩耍情境。在本研究中,我们旨在补充在积极情境下感染的观察证据,同时区分行为感染和情绪感染的各个方面。在一组非繁殖期的普通渡鸦中,我们研究了目睹同种个体进行积极的社交互动,即相互梳理羽毛,是否会影响旁观者的行为以及可能的情绪状态。我们记录了旁观者在梳理羽毛后观察阶段的行为表现,并将其与匹配的对照观察阶段进行比较。我们发现,目睹其他渡鸦相互梳理羽毛对旁观者随后的亲和互动有影响,但对它们的自我导向行为(如自我梳理羽毛)或争斗互动没有影响。具体而言,旁观者在梳理羽毛后观察阶段比在匹配的对照观察阶段更有可能自己进行相互梳理羽毛,这可以通过行为感染和情绪感染来解释;然而,旁观者在观察其他渡鸦相互梳理羽毛后,非梳理羽毛的亲和互动水平也有所提高,并且与同种个体待在一起的时间更长,这暗示了对旁观者情绪状态有更普遍的影响。这些非梳理羽毛的亲和互动是否确实是情绪感染的一种表现,需要在进一步测量和操纵情绪状态的研究中进行检验。