Alsouri Ruba Kamal, Khader Yousef, Bashier Haitham, Amiri Mirwais, Morsy Sara Abdelkarim, Abbas Zainab Naseer, Farah Zeina Elias, Al Nsour Mohannad
Global Health Development, Eastern Mediterranean Public Health Network, Amman, Jordan.
Department of Community Medicine, Public Health, and Family Medicine/Faculty of Medicine, Jordan University of Science and Technology, Ar-Ramtha, Jordan.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2024 Jul 15;11:1391219. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2024.1391219. eCollection 2024.
The COVID-19 pandemic encouraged the shift toward technology-based learning globally, impacting education systems profoundly. In response to this emerging need, the Eastern Mediterranean Public Health Network (EMPHNET) adapted its Public Health Empowerment Program-Basic Field Epidemiology (PHEP-BFE) to a Blended Learning Model. This study evaluates the Blended PHEP-BFE program in Iraq, Egypt, and Lebanon, focusing on participant reactions and learning outcomes.
A descriptive evaluation was conducted, aligned with the first two levels of Kirkpatrick's model. Online questionnaires were administered to participants and facilitators through EMPHNET's Learning Management System (LMS). Qualitative and quantitative data were analyzed to assess program effectiveness, satisfaction, and challenges.
A total of 138 PHEP-BFE participants (119 (86.2%) males and 19 (13.8%) females) from Iraq ( = 61), Egypt ( = 66), and Lebanon ( = 11) responded to the questionnaire. The majority of the participants (96.4%) reported that they were satisfied with PHEP-BFE. Notably, 77.5% of participants rated the blended learning program as very good or excellent, 18.1% rated it good, and 3.6% found it average, with a minimal 0.7% expressing dissatisfaction. The majority of participants agreed that the blended PHEP-BFE enhanced their capacity to conduct, review and monitor surveillance data (95.7%), perform descriptive data analysis (94.2%), effectively communicate information with agency staff and the local community (95.7%), write summaries of surveillance findings or outbreak investigations (95.7%), use MS Excel to enter, analyze, and display public health surveillance data (91.3%), prepare and administer an oral presentation for fieldwork (94.9%), and increase their knowledge of fundamental field epidemiology (94.9%). The participants responded positively to the program's content, training duration, learning platform, facilitators and mentors, and fieldwork.
The study showcases the success of the blended PHEP-BFE in diverse contexts, emphasizing positive participant reactions and improved competencies. The evaluation underscores the program's success in advancing public health training in the EMR. Blended learning models prove promising for future FETP initiatives, contributing valuable insights to public health workforce development. Positive outcomes and identified challenges, provide a roadmap for continuous improvement.
新冠疫情促使全球向基于技术的学习转变,对教育系统产生了深远影响。为应对这一新兴需求,东地中海公共卫生网络(EMPHNET)将其公共卫生赋权计划 - 基础现场流行病学(PHEP - BFE)调整为混合学习模式。本研究评估了伊拉克、埃及和黎巴嫩的混合式PHEP - BFE计划,重点关注参与者的反应和学习成果。
进行了一项描述性评估,与柯克帕特里克模型的前两个层次一致。通过EMPHNET的学习管理系统(LMS)向参与者和辅导员发放在线问卷。对定性和定量数据进行分析,以评估计划的有效性、满意度和挑战。
来自伊拉克(n = 61)、埃及(n = 66)和黎巴嫩(n = 11)的138名PHEP - BFE参与者(119名(86.2%)男性和19名(13.8%)女性)回复了问卷。大多数参与者(96.4%)表示对PHEP - BFE感到满意。值得注意的是,77.5%的参与者将混合学习计划评为非常好或优秀,18.1%评为好,3.6%认为一般,只有0.