Liedo Belen
Institute of Philosophy, Spanish National Research Council, Madrid, Madrid, Spain.
Bioethics. 2025 Jun;39(5):448-455. doi: 10.1111/bioe.13340. Epub 2024 Jul 31.
In this article, I propose an ethical analysis of assistive domestic robots for older users. In doing so, I illustrate my inquiry with the example of ROB-IN assistive robot. ROB-IN is a Spanish project which is devoted to developing a robot that will perform in the private home of nondependent, aged users. It is aimed to help people in their daily activities and contribute to appropriate health monitoring. One of their potentially most useful features is related to data gathering and sharing. For the inquiry on the ethical underpinnings of this case, I develop a framework for domestic assistive robots for competent older adults drawn on the ethics of care. I assess that this type of robots could be ethically appraised attending to their impact on the well-being and autonomy of users. I approach autonomy from a relational perspective, and I delve into the relationship between autonomy and well-being through the concept of paternalism. I argue that this type of assistive robots should never act paternalistically. Given ROB-IN great implications regarding privacy, I subsequently explore the ways in which the privacy of users should be respected in their interaction with assistive robots, focusing on the relation with autonomy and well-being. Lastly, I highlight the need for avoiding ageism. This investigation focuses on aged users, but it is suggested that the situation of caregivers should be also the object of further investigations.
在本文中,我对面向老年用户的家用辅助机器人进行了伦理分析。在此过程中,我以ROB-IN辅助机器人为例来说明我的探究。ROB-IN是一个西班牙项目,致力于开发一种能在独立老年用户家中发挥作用的机器人。其目的是帮助人们进行日常活动,并有助于进行适当的健康监测。其最具潜在用途的功能之一与数据收集和共享有关。为了探究该案例的伦理基础,我基于关怀伦理为有行为能力的老年人开发了一个家用辅助机器人框架。我评估认为,可以从这类机器人对用户福祉和自主性的影响方面对其进行伦理评价。我从关系视角探讨自主性,并通过家长主义概念深入研究自主性与福祉之间的关系。我认为这类辅助机器人绝不应该采取家长式行为。鉴于ROB-IN在隐私方面有重大影响,随后我探讨了在用户与辅助机器人互动中应如何尊重用户隐私,重点关注与自主性和福祉的关系。最后,我强调了避免年龄歧视的必要性。本调查聚焦于老年用户,但也有人建议,护理人员的情况也应成为进一步调查的对象。