Prognostic significance of T3b in papillary thyroid carcinoma: Appropriateness of classifying T3bN0M0 in patients aged 55 years or older into stage II.

BACKGROUND

Papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) often extends to adjacent organs. According to the 8th Tumor-Node-Metastasis Classification, extension to the strap muscles was graded as T3b. We investigated the prognostic impact of T3b and the appropriateness of T3b in patients aged ≥55 years who were classified as stage II.

METHODS

We enrolled 7811 patients with M0 PTC who underwent initial surgery at the Kuma Hospital (Kobe, Japan) between January 2007 and December 2016. Tumor extension was divided into T3b, T4a1 (extension to the tracheal adventitia, tracheal cartilage, esophageal muscle layer, recurrent laryngeal nerve, cricothyroid, and inferior constrictor muscles), and sT4a2 (extension to the subcutaneous soft tissues, tracheal mucosa, esophageal mucosa, internal jugular vein, brachiocephalic vein, larynx, pharynx, and sternocleidomastoid muscle).

RESULTS

In patients ≥55 years, the local recurrence-free survival (LR-FS), distant recurrence-free survival (DR-FS), and cause-specific survival (CSS) rates of T3bN0M0 were significantly poorer than those of T1/T2N0M0 but did not significantly differ from those of T3aN0M0. The LR-FS, DR-FS, and CSS rates of T3b stage II patients did not differ from those of T4a1 stage III patients but were significantly better than those of T4a2 stage III patients. T3b was an independent predictor of local recurrence and distant recurrence but not of death due to carcinoma in the multivariate analysis. In patients aged <55 years with M0 PTC, T3b had no prognostic value in both analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

T3bM0 patients are appropriate to be classified as stage II in patients ≥55 years but be kept in stage I in patients <55 years.