Bernier Jessica, Breton Mylaine, Poitras Marie-Eve
Department of Family Medicine and Emergency Medicine, University of Sherbrooke, Saguenay-Lac-St-Jean, 305, Saint-Vallier, Chicoutimi, Québec, G7H 5H6, Canada.
Department of Community Health Sciences, Université de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Jul 31;24(1):869. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-11321-4.
Cardiovascular disease is the leading cause of death worldwide. Cardiac rehabilitation (CR) programs are recognized as effective in reducing the burden of cardiovascular disease. However, CR programs are offered inequitably across regions and are available in less than 15% of remote areas worldwide. The main goal of this study was to design a CR program adapted to the contexts of remote areas to improve the service offered to patients.
We used an iterative user-centered design approach to understand the user context and services offered in cardiac rehabilitation in remote areas. We conducted two co-design processes with knowledge users in two remote regions. Two advisory committees were created in each of these regions, comprising managers (n = 6), healthcare professionals (n = 12) and patients (n = 2). We utilized the BACPR guidelines and the Hautes Autorités de santé operational model to support data collection in coding sessions to develop the CR program. We conducted four cycles of co-design with each of the committees to develop the cardiac rehabilitation program. Qualitative data were analyzed iteratively after each cycle.
The co-design process resulted in developing a prototype cardiac rehabilitation program similar in both regions. It is based on a contextualized six-phase pathway of care designed for remote regions. For each phase 0 to 6 of the care pathway, knowledge users were asked to describe how to offer these phases in remote areas. Participants made structural changes to phases 0, 2, 3 and 4 in order to overcome staffing shortages in remote areas. These changes make it possible to decentralize cardiac rehabilitation expertise away from specialized centers, to ensure equity of service across the territory. Therapeutic patient education was integrated into phase 4 to meet patients' needs. Participants suggested that three follow-up offerings could come from nursing services to increase access to the cardiac rehabilitation program (primary care, home care, special chronic disease programs) in patients' home communities.
The co-design process enables us to meet the needs of remote regions in program development. This final program can be the subject of future implementation research.
心血管疾病是全球主要的死亡原因。心脏康复(CR)项目被认为在减轻心血管疾病负担方面有效。然而,CR项目在各地区的提供情况不均衡,全球不到15%的偏远地区有该项目。本研究的主要目标是设计一个适应偏远地区情况的CR项目,以改善为患者提供的服务。
我们采用了以用户为中心的迭代设计方法,以了解偏远地区心脏康复的用户情况和提供的服务。我们在两个偏远地区与知识用户进行了两个共同设计过程。在每个地区都成立了两个咨询委员会,成员包括管理人员(n = 6)、医疗保健专业人员(n = 12)和患者(n = 2)。我们利用英国心血管预防与康复协会(BACPR)指南和法国卫生高级管理局的运营模式,支持在编码会议中收集数据,以制定CR项目。我们与每个委员会进行了四个周期的共同设计,以制定心脏康复项目。每个周期后对定性数据进行迭代分析。
共同设计过程导致在两个地区都开发出了一个类似的心脏康复项目原型。它基于为偏远地区设计的情境化六阶段护理路径。对于护理路径的每个阶段0到6,知识用户被要求描述如何在偏远地区提供这些阶段的服务。参与者对阶段0、2、3和4进行了结构调整,以克服偏远地区人员短缺的问题。这些变化使得心脏康复专业知识能够从专业中心分散开来,以确保整个地区服务的公平性。治疗性患者教育被纳入阶段4,以满足患者的需求。参与者建议,护理服务可以提供三种后续服务,以增加患者所在社区获得心脏康复项目(初级保健、家庭护理、特殊慢性病项目)的机会。
共同设计过程使我们能够在项目开发中满足偏远地区的需求。这个最终项目可以成为未来实施研究的主题。