Canadian Centre for Rural and Agricultural Health, University of Saskatchewan, 104 Clinic Place, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan (SK), SK S7N 2Z4, Canada.
Department of Psychology, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, SK, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Jun 13;24(1):725. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-11167-w.
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: As part of a larger study, and in collaboration with rural primary health care teams, RaDAR (Rural Dementia Action Research) primary care memory clinics have evolved and continue to spread in communities across southeast Saskatchewan, Canada. This study focuses on the geographical areas of the four communities where RaDAR memory clinics were first developed and implemented and describes the services and supports available to older adults including memory clinic patients and families living in these areas. Our goal was to identify and describe existing programs and gaps, create inventories and maps, and explore the service experiences of family caregivers of people living with dementia in these rural areas.
Using a qualitative descriptive design, an environmental scan of services was conducted from December 2020 to April 2021 using focus groups (n = 4) with health care providers/managers (n = 12), a secondary source (e.g., program brochures) review, and a systematic internet search targeting four RaDAR memory clinic communities and surrounding areas via community websites, online resources, and the 211 Saskatchewan service database. Data were analyzed using content analysis; findings informed semi-structured interviews with caregivers (n = 5) conducted from March to July 2022, which were analyzed thematically. Geographic areas explored in this study covered an area of approximately 5666 km.
From the scan, 43 services were identified, categorized into 7 service types, and mapped by location. Seventeen services were dementia-related. Services included social/leisure activities (n = 14), general support/referrals (n = 13), transportation (n = 7), information/education (n = 4), respite (n = 2), in-home care (n = 2), and safety (n = 1). Service levels included local (n = 24), provincial (n = 17), and national (n = 2), and were offered in-person, remotely (or both) with 20 services across 4 service types offered remotely. In general, most services had no fees, involved self-referral, and providers had a range of education/training. Key interview themes reflected the need for locally available, accessible services that offer (i) individualized, flexible, needs-based approaches, (ii) in-home care and continuity of care, and (iii) both formal and informal supports. Key gaps were identified, including (i) locally accessible, available services and resources in general, (ii) dementia-related training and education for service providers, and (iii) awareness of available services. Benefits of services, consequences of gaps, and recommendations to address gaps were reported. In general, service providers and program participants were an even mix of females and males, and program content was gender neutral.
Findings highlight a range of available services, and a number of varied service-user experiences and perspectives, in these rural areas. Key service gaps were identified, and caregivers made some specific recommendations to address these gaps. Findings underscore multiple opportunities to inform service delivery and program participation for rural and remote people living with dementia and their families.
背景/目的:作为一项更大研究的一部分,并与农村初级保健团队合作,RaDAR(农村痴呆症行动研究)初级保健记忆诊所不断发展,并继续在加拿大萨斯喀彻温省东南部的各个社区中传播。本研究集中在 RaDAR 记忆诊所最初开发和实施的四个社区的地理区域,并描述了为居住在这些地区的老年人提供的服务和支持,包括记忆诊所患者和家庭。我们的目标是确定和描述现有的计划和差距,创建清单和地图,并探索这些农村地区患有痴呆症的人的家庭照顾者的服务体验。
使用定性描述设计,我们于 2020 年 12 月至 2021 年 4 月间使用焦点小组(n=4)(n=12)与医疗保健提供者/经理进行了服务环境扫描,使用了健康护理提供者/经理(n=12),对二级来源(例如,项目手册)进行了审查,并通过社区网站、在线资源和 211 萨斯喀彻温省服务数据库对 RaDAR 记忆诊所社区及其周边地区进行了有针对性的系统互联网搜索。使用内容分析对数据进行分析;调查结果为 2022 年 3 月至 7 月期间对 5 名照顾者进行的半结构式访谈提供了信息,这些访谈进行了主题分析。本研究中探索的地理区域约为 5666 平方公里。
从扫描中确定了 43 项服务,将其分为 7 种服务类型,并按位置进行了映射。其中 17 项服务与痴呆症有关。这些服务包括社交/休闲活动(n=14)、一般支持/转介(n=13)、交通(n=7)、信息/教育(n=4)、暂托(n=2)、家庭护理(n=2)和安全(n=1)。服务级别包括本地(n=24)、省级(n=17)和国家级(n=2),以现场、远程(或两者兼而有之)的方式提供,其中 4 种服务类型中的 20 种服务以远程方式提供。总的来说,大多数服务是免费的,需要自我推荐,并且提供服务的人员具有不同程度的教育/培训。关键访谈主题反映了对本地提供的、易于获取的服务的需求,这些服务提供了(i)个性化、灵活、基于需求的方法,(ii)家庭护理和持续护理,以及(iii)正式和非正式的支持。确定了一些关键差距,包括(i)本地获取、可用的服务和资源,(ii)服务提供者的痴呆症相关培训和教育,以及(iii)对可用服务的认识。报告了服务的好处、差距的后果以及解决差距的建议。总的来说,服务提供者和项目参与者中男女比例相当,项目内容是性别中立的。
研究结果突出了这些农村地区一系列现有的服务以及各种不同的服务使用者体验和观点。确定了一些关键的服务差距,并提出了一些具体的建议来解决这些差距。研究结果强调了为农村和偏远地区的痴呆症患者及其家属提供服务和参与项目的多个机会。