Emergency Department, Al-Thawra Modern General Hospital, Sana'a, Yemen.
Pediatric Emergency Department, Department of Pediatrics, St. Christopher's Hospital, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
BMC Public Health. 2024 Aug 1;24(1):2081. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-19575-7.
Effective education is considered by the American Heart Association (AHA) as a vital variable in improving outcomes of cardiac arrest. Studies have shown that the level of knowledge and attitude of non-healthcare providers towards resuscitation training varies widely across the globe. While some training methods and barriers to training have been discussed, the literature is still quite vague and unclear regarding resuscitation training, particularly in the Middle East. This study's focus on the efficacy of resuscitation training in this region of the world may help dictate how to better implement education initiatives aimed towards non-healthcare providers in developing countries.
A systematic review and meta-analysis were conducted on studies published from inception until March 2023. Observational studies assessing CPR knowledge and skills among non-healthcare workers in Arab countries were included. Data were extracted from PubMed, Cochrane Library, EMBASE, Web of Science, and Scopus. Data analysis was performed using Rstudio with a random effects model.
50 studies were included in this review and meta-analysis, revealing that 55% of participants had prior knowledge of CPR, while only 28% considered their knowledge sufficient. The majority (76%) supported mandatory CPR training, and 86% were willing to attend training if offered. This study found that prior knowledge of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) varied among populations. This meta-analysis also compiled results regarding CPR technique defined by correct compression to ventilation ratio, compression depth, compression rate, location of chest compression, and correct sequence. The overall results from this meta-analysis showed that, of these factors, compression rate and depth were the two factors that were most often administered incorrectly. In all, the results from this study demonstrated that CPR training in Arab countries was favorably viewed overall, with the majority of participants indicating both support for mandatory CPR training and general willingness to attend training if offered the opportunity.
Given the overall positive view and willingness to learn CPR skills, healthcare policy makers should adopt a more comprehensive focus on strategies that enhance the accessibility and opportunity for CPR training for non-healthcare populations in Arab countries. Future training programs should implement strategies to highlight the ideal combination of compression rates and depth to learners to ensure correct and efficacious delivery of CPR with increased focus on the practical portion during refresher courses to promote retention.
美国心脏协会(AHA)认为,有效的教育是改善心脏骤停结局的重要因素。研究表明,非医疗保健提供者对复苏培训的知识水平和态度在全球范围内差异很大。虽然已经讨论了一些培训方法和培训障碍,但关于复苏培训的文献仍然相当模糊和不清楚,特别是在中东地区。本研究关注该地区复苏培训的效果,可能有助于确定如何更好地为发展中国家的非医疗保健提供者实施教育计划。
对截至 2023 年 3 月发表的研究进行了系统回顾和荟萃分析。纳入评估阿拉伯国家非卫生保健工作者心肺复苏(CPR)知识和技能的观察性研究。从 PubMed、Cochrane 图书馆、EMBASE、Web of Science 和 Scopus 提取数据。使用 Rstudio 进行数据分析,采用随机效应模型。
本综述和荟萃分析纳入了 50 项研究,结果显示,55%的参与者事先了解 CPR,而只有 28%的人认为自己的知识足够。大多数(76%)支持强制性 CPR 培训,如果提供培训,86%的人愿意参加。本研究发现,心肺复苏术(CPR)的先前知识在人群中有所不同。该荟萃分析还汇编了有关 CPR 技术的结果,包括正确的按压通气比、按压深度、按压频率、胸部按压位置和正确的按压顺序。本荟萃分析的总体结果表明,在这些因素中,按压频率和深度是最常不正确实施的两个因素。总的来说,这项研究的结果表明,CPR 培训在阿拉伯国家总体上受到好评,大多数参与者表示,他们不仅支持强制性 CPR 培训,而且如果有机会,普遍愿意参加培训。
鉴于总体上对学习 CPR 技能的积极态度和意愿,医疗保健政策制定者应更加全面地关注增强阿拉伯国家非医疗保健人群获得 CPR 培训的机会和途径的策略。未来的培训计划应实施策略,向学习者强调理想的按压频率和深度组合,以确保 CPR 的正确和有效实施,并在复习课程中更加注重实践部分,以促进知识的保留。