Durler Shelby, Lightwine Kelly, Ablah Elizabeth, Cox Thomas D, Haan James M
University of Kansas School of Medicine-Wichita, Wichita, KS.
Ascension Via Christi Hospital, Wichita, KS.
Kans J Med. 2024 Jul 24;17(4):78-80. doi: 10.17161/kjm.vol17.21379. eCollection 2024.
This study evaluated the presence of neurologic sequelae among trauma patients after flexion-extension (F/E) radiographs.
Authors of the study conducted a retrospective review of patients (age ≥ 14 years) with a Glasgow Coma Score of 15 who sustained a blunt traumatic injury and received F/E radiographs. Radiographic scans were defined as positive, negative, inconclusive, or incomplete. The neurologic status of each patient was assessed before and after the F/E radiographs, and at discharge and follow-up.
Of the 501 patients included in the analysis, 84.6% (n = 424) had negative F/E radiographs, and 3.2% (n = 16) had positive F/E radiographs. Ten percent (n = 51) of patients had incomplete F/E radiographs, and 2.0% (n = 10) were inconclusive due to the inability to rule out a ligamentous injury. Three patients (0.6%) had MRI-confirmed ligamentous injuries, all of which had initial incomplete F/E radiographs due to pain. No patient had a documented neurological deficit before or after the F/E exam. Three patients with an initial negative F/E radiograph returned to the clinic with symptoms of neurologic sequelae. Two of these patients had symptom resolution with no further issues at future follow-up appointments. The third patient was found to have chronic neurologic symptoms after further evaluation.
The inclusion of F/E exams in cervical spine clearance protocols did not demonstrate any new long-term iatrogenic neurologic injuries. Consideration should be given to performing MRIs on patients with incomplete F/E radiographs that cannot rule out a ligamentous injury.
本研究评估了屈伸(F/E)位X线片检查后创伤患者神经后遗症的存在情况。
该研究的作者对格拉斯哥昏迷评分为15分、遭受钝性创伤并接受F/E位X线片检查的患者(年龄≥14岁)进行了回顾性分析。X线扫描被定义为阳性、阴性、不确定或不完整。在F/E位X线片检查前后、出院时及随访时评估每位患者的神经状态。
纳入分析的501例患者中,84.6%(n = 424)的F/E位X线片为阴性,3.2%(n = 16)为阳性。10%(n = 51)的患者F/E位X线片不完整,2.0%(n = 10)因无法排除韧带损伤而结果不确定。3例患者(0.6%)经MRI证实有韧带损伤,均因疼痛导致最初的F/E位X线片不完整。F/E位X线片检查前后均无患者有记录在案的神经功能缺损。3例最初F/E位X线片为阴性的患者因神经后遗症症状返回诊所。其中2例患者症状缓解,在未来随访时无进一步问题。第3例患者经进一步评估发现有慢性神经症状。
在颈椎评估方案中纳入F/E位X线片检查未显示任何新的长期医源性神经损伤。对于F/E位X线片不完整且无法排除韧带损伤的患者,应考虑进行MRI检查。