Iivanainen Antti, Collares Carlos Fernando, Wandall Jakob, Parpala Anna, Nevgi Anne, Keto-Timonen Riikka, Tipold Andrea, Schaper Elisabeth, van Haeften Theo, Pihl Tina Holberg, Press Charles McLean, Holm Peter
Department of Biosciences, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland.
Medical Education Unit, Faculty of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, University of Algarve, Faro, Portugal.
Front Vet Sci. 2024 Jul 18;11:1292750. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2024.1292750. eCollection 2024.
This study investigates the relationship between approaches to learning, self-perceived study burnout, and the level of knowledge among veterinary students. Veterinary educational programs are under regular development and would benefit greatly from detailed feedback on students' knowledge, proficiency, influencing factors, and coping mechanisms.
The VetRepos consortium developed and calibrated an item repository testing knowledge across the entire veterinary curriculum. Two hundred forty-eight students from seven European veterinary institutions took the VetRepos test, comprising a subset of the repository. They also responded to a questionnaire assessing deep and unreflective learning approaches and self-perceived study burnout, represented by exhaustion and cynicism. Structural equation modeling analyzed the relationship between these latent traits and the VetRepos test score.
The model failed the exact-fit test but was retained based on global fit indices, inter-item residual correlations, and standardized residual covariances. Root Mean Square Error of Approximation with robust standard errors and scaled test statistic was 0.049 (95% confidence interval 0.033-0.071), scaled and robust Comparative Fit Index 0.95 (0.90-0.98), and scaled Standardized Root Mean Square Residual 0.056 (0.049-0.071). Measurement invariance across study years was not violated (ΔCFI = 0.00, χ = 3.78, Δdf = 4, = 0.44), but it could not be confirmed between genders or universities. The VetRepos test score regressed on the study year [standardized regression coefficient = 0.68 (0.62-0.73)], showed a negative regression on the unreflective learning approach [-0.25 (-0.47 to -0.03)], and a positive regression on the deep approach [0.16 (0.03-0.28)]. No direct association with perceived burnout was observed; however, a significant, medium-sized association was found between the unreflective approach and self-perceived study burnout. No significant differences in learning approaches or perceived burnout were found between study years.
The most important source of variance in VetRepos test scores, unrelated to the study year, was the learning approach. The association between the VetRepos test score and self-perceived burnout was indirect. Future research should complement this cross-sectional approach with longitudinal and person-oriented studies, further investigating the relationship between study burnout and learning approaches.
本研究调查了兽医专业学生的学习方法、自我感知的学习倦怠与知识水平之间的关系。兽医教育项目正在不断发展,若能获得有关学生知识、能力、影响因素及应对机制的详细反馈,将受益匪浅。
VetRepos联盟开发并校准了一个项目库,用于测试整个兽医课程的知识。来自七所欧洲兽医机构的248名学生参加了VetRepos测试,该测试是项目库的一个子集。他们还回答了一份问卷,评估深度学习和非反思性学习方法以及以疲惫和玩世不恭为代表的自我感知的学习倦怠。结构方程模型分析了这些潜在特征与VetRepos测试分数之间的关系。
该模型未通过精确拟合检验,但基于整体拟合指数、项目间残差相关性和标准化残差协方差得以保留。稳健标准误差和缩放检验统计量的近似均方根误差为0.049(95%置信区间0.033 - 0.071),缩放和稳健比较拟合指数为0.95(0.90 - 0.98),缩放标准化均方根残差为0.056(0.049 - 0.071)。各学习年份之间未违反测量不变性(ΔCFI = 0.00,χ = 3.78,Δdf = 4, = 0.44),但无法在性别或大学之间得到证实。VetRepos测试分数对学习年份的回归系数为[标准化回归系数 = 0.68(0. .62 - 0.73)],对非反思性学习方法呈负回归[-0.25(-0.47至-0.03)],对深度学习方法呈正回归[0.16(0.03 - 0.28)]。未观察到与感知倦怠的直接关联;然而,在非反思性学习方法与自我感知的学习倦怠之间发现了显著的中等程度关联。各学习年份之间在学习方法或感知倦怠方面未发现显著差异。
VetRepos测试分数中与学习年份无关的最重要变异来源是学习方法。VetRepos测试分数与自我感知的倦怠之间的关联是间接的。未来的研究应以纵向和以人为本的研究补充这种横断面研究方法,进一步探究学习倦怠与学习方法之间的关系。