Brighton and Sussex Medical School (BSMS), University of Sussex, Brighton, United Kingdom.
PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2024 Aug 2;18(8):e0012391. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0012391. eCollection 2024 Aug.
Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTDs) disproportionately affect marginalised groups within impoverished communities, conferring devastating physical, financial and psychosocial effects. Skin-NTDs (SNTDs) are uniquely stigmatising due to their visible nature, rendering affected individuals vulnerable to psychosocial risk and the associated decline in social participation, quality of life and mental health. In response to knowledge gaps identified by current global efforts for integrated control of SNTDs this review gathers existing evidence on the psychosocial effects of SNTDs, with consideration given to the influence of gender.
The study protocol is registered with PROSPERO (CRD42022336676). Data was collected from Embase, Global Health, Medline and Web of Science, with additional articles identified through Google Scholar and bibliography tracking. Qualitative studies published in English between 2005 and 2024 reporting men's and women's experiences with SNTDs were searched. Appropriate data from each included study were inputted into NVivo software to facilitate thematic synthesis. Descriptive and analytic themes were generated through line-by-line coding using an inductive approach.
27 articles of high and moderate quality were included. They pertained to buruli ulcer, cutaneous leishmaniasis, leprosy, lymphatic filariasis, tungiasis, onchocerciasis, schistosomiasis and podoconiosis. Men and women across SNTDs and contexts reported debilitating physical symptoms which impaired their ability to work, socialise and carry out usual daily activities. Some felt (at least initially) well supported by partners and relatives, whereas most experienced avoidance, abandonment and even violence, with women incurring worse SNTD-related social consequences. Many men and most women experienced stigma, with discriminatory behaviours largely attributed to fear of infection, decreased ability to perform gender-specific daily activities, and the perceived association between SNTDs and sinfulness. Self-reported impacts of SNTDs on men's and women's mental wellbeing included low mood, anxiety, low self-esteem, and suicidal ideation. Disease-specific knowledge, early treatment, social support, and disease acceptance were mentioned as protective factors.
SNTDs cause significant psychosocial harms, particularly for women. Implementing myth-busting and contact-based educational campaigns and improving access to treatment and to livelihood opportunities and social protection schemes for men and women with a SNTD will help prevent and mitigate these.
被忽视的热带病(NTDs)不成比例地影响贫困社区中的边缘化群体,给他们带来毁灭性的身体、经济和社会心理影响。皮肤 NTDs(SNTDs)由于其可见性而具有独特的污名化特征,使受影响的个人容易面临社会心理风险,以及随之而来的社会参与度下降、生活质量下降和心理健康受损。针对当前全球综合控制 SNTD 努力中确定的知识空白,本综述收集了关于 SNTDs 的社会心理影响的现有证据,并考虑了性别的影响。
本研究方案在 PROSPERO(CRD42022336676)上注册。数据来自 Embase、全球健康、Medline 和 Web of Science,并通过 Google Scholar 和参考文献追踪进一步确定了其他文章。搜索了 2005 年至 2024 年期间以英文发表的报告男性和女性 SNTDs 经历的定性研究。从每个纳入研究中提取适当的数据,输入到 NVivo 软件中,以促进主题综合。通过使用归纳方法进行逐行编码,生成描述性和分析性主题。
纳入了 27 篇高质量和中等质量的文章。它们涉及到布鲁里溃疡、皮肤利什曼病、麻风病、淋巴丝虫病、麦地那龙线虫病、盘尾丝虫病、血吸虫病和 Podoconiosis。患有 SNTDs 的男性和女性在不同的环境中报告了衰弱的身体症状,这些症状影响了他们工作、社交和进行日常活动的能力。一些人(至少最初)得到了伴侣和亲属的良好支持,而大多数人则经历了回避、抛弃,甚至暴力,女性遭受了更严重的与 SNTDs 相关的社会后果。许多男性和大多数女性经历了污名化,歧视行为主要归因于对感染的恐惧、进行特定性别日常活动的能力下降,以及 SNTDs 与罪恶感之间的关联。SNTDs 对男性和女性心理健康的自我报告影响包括情绪低落、焦虑、自尊心低和自杀意念。疾病特异性知识、早期治疗、社会支持以及对 SNTDs 的接受被认为是保护因素。
SNTDs 会造成严重的社会心理伤害,尤其是对女性而言。实施破除迷信和基于接触的教育活动,并改善男性和女性 SNTD 患者的治疗机会、生计机会和社会保护计划,将有助于预防和减轻这些伤害。