Introduction Spine fracture in association with traumatic dural tear is a serious injury. A traumatic dural tear is difficult to determine based on initial clinical presentation and radiological imaging even with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). However, during decompression surgery, cerebrospinal fluid leaks surrounding the injured segments are usually confirmed by directly visualizing them. For preoperative planning and intraoperatively limiting further damage to the dural and neurological structures, early detection of traumatic dural tears before surgery is important. This study aims to determine the prevalence, implication, risk factors, and complications of traumatic dural tears in patients who have undergone surgical treatment for thoracic and lumbar fractures. We believe our retrospective study would identify more accurate risk factors for traumatic dural tears and aid us with preoperative planning and operative precaution. Methods This study retrospectively included all patients who had thoracic and lumbar fractures and had posterior instrumentation and decompression surgery at three hospitals in the Northern region of Malaysia from January 2018 to December 2020. Fractures associated with pathological spine including metastatic, severe osteoporosis, ankylosing spondylitis, metabolic bone disease, those with missing data, and iatrogenic dural tears were excluded from this study. Preoperative and postoperative neurological assessments based on the American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) impairment scale, blood loss volume, duration of the surgery, and post-surgery complications were gathered from medical records. Interpedicular distance, ratio of central canal diameter, laminar fracture gap, and pedicle fractures were identified and measured. The obtained data was analyzed using Pearson's chi-square and Fisher's exact test for categorical variables, and independent t-test/Mann-Whitney test for numerical variables. Result This study comprised a total of 93 patients who had fractures in their thoracic and lumbar regions. The mean age of the patients was 38 years. The number of patients with traumatic dural tears was 20 (21.5%). There was an association between the presence of dural tears and preoperative neurological deficits (P<0.001). Wider mean interpedicular distance (P=0.004), increased central canal diameter ratio (P<0.001), and displaced laminar fracture (P<0.001) were significantly higher in patients with traumatic dural tears. Multiple logistic regression analysis showed both incomplete (P=0.002) and complete (P=0.037) preoperative neurological deficit, increase of central diameter ratio of encroachment (P=0.011), and presence of >2mm laminar fracture gap (P=0.015) had a significant association with a traumatic dural tear. This study found that patients with traumatic dural tears had longer surgical times and statistically larger mean blood loss volumes when compared to patients without dural tears (P<0.001). There is no significant association between the complications following the surgery and the presence of a dural tear (P>0.05).  Conclusion This study shows that the presence of preoperative neurological deficits, wider interpedicular distance, severe canal encroachment, and wide separation of laminar fracture may indicate the likelihood of traumatic dural tear in spine fracture. These factors will enable surgeons to enhance their operational planning and make early preparations for the management of dural tears.