Urien Jean Marie, Berthelot Emmanuelle, Raphael Pierre, Moine Thomas, Lopes Marie Emilie, Assayag Patrick, Jourdain Patrick
CHU Bicêtre, Le Kremlin Bicêtre, France.
Institut du cœur saint Gatien, Tours, France.
JMIR Cardio. 2024 Aug 13;8:e52648. doi: 10.2196/52648.
BACKGROUND: For a decade, despite results from many studies, telemedicine systems have suffered from a lack of recommendations for chronic heart failure (CHF) care because of variable study results. Another limitation is the hospital-based architecture of most telemedicine systems. Some systems use an algorithm based on daily weight, transcutaneous oxygen measurement, and heart rate to detect and treat acute heart failure (AHF) in patients with CHF as early on as possible. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to determine the efficacy of a telemonitoring system in detecting clinical destabilization in real-life settings (out-of-hospital management) without generating too many false positive alerts. METHODS: All patients self-monitoring at home using the system after a congestive AHF event treated at a cardiology clinic in France between March 2020 and March 2021 with at least 75% compliance on daily measurements were included retrospectively. New-onset AHF was defined by the presence of at least 1 of the following criteria: transcutaneous oxygen saturation loss, defined as a transcutaneous oxygen measurement under 90%; rise of cardiac frequency above 110 beats per minute; weight gain of at least 2 kg; and symptoms of congestive AHF, described over the phone. An AHF alert was generated when the criteria reached our definition of new-onset acute congestive heart failure (HF). RESULTS: A total of 111 consecutive patients (n=70 men) with a median age of 76.60 (IQR 69.5-83.4) years receiving the telemonitoring system were included. Thirty-nine patients (35.1%) reached the HF warning level, and 28 patients (25%) had confirmed HF destabilization during follow-up. No patient had AHF without being detected by the telemonitoring system. Among incorrect AHF alerts (n=11), 5 patients (45%) had taken inaccurate measurements, 3 patients (27%) had supraventricular arrhythmia, 1 patient (9%) had a pulmonary bacterial infection, and 1 patient (9%) contracted COVID-19. A weight gain of at least 2 kg within 4 days was significantly associated with a correct AHF alert (P=.004), and a heart rate of more than 110 beats per minute was more significantly associated with an incorrect AHF alert (P=.007). CONCLUSIONS: This single-center study highlighted the efficacy of the telemedicine system in detecting and quickly treating cardiac instability complicating the course of CHF by detecting new-onset AHF as well as supraventricular arrhythmia, thus helping cardiologists provide better follow-up to ambulatory patients.
背景:十年来,尽管有许多研究成果,但由于研究结果不一,远程医疗系统在慢性心力衰竭(CHF)护理方面一直缺乏相关建议。另一个局限性是大多数远程医疗系统基于医院的架构。一些系统使用基于每日体重、经皮氧测量和心率的算法,尽早检测和治疗CHF患者的急性心力衰竭(AHF)。 目的:本研究的目的是确定远程监测系统在现实生活环境(院外管理)中检测临床失稳而不产生过多误报的有效性。 方法:回顾性纳入2020年3月至2021年3月在法国一家心脏病诊所接受充血性AHF事件治疗后在家中使用该系统进行自我监测且每日测量依从性至少达75%的所有患者。新发AHF定义为存在以下至少1项标准:经皮氧饱和度下降,定义为经皮氧测量低于90%;心率上升超过每分钟110次;体重增加至少2 kg;以及通过电话描述的充血性AHF症状。当标准达到我们对新发急性充血性心力衰竭(HF)的定义时,即生成AHF警报。 结果:总共纳入了111例连续接受远程监测系统的患者(n = 70名男性),中位年龄为76.60(四分位间距69.5 - 83.4)岁。39例患者(35.1%)达到HF警告水平,28例患者(25%)在随访期间确诊HF失稳。没有患者发生未被远程监测系统检测到的AHF。在错误的AHF警报(n = 11)中,5例患者(45%)测量不准确,3例患者(27%)有室上性心律失常,1例患者(9%)有肺部细菌感染,1例患者(9%)感染了COVID - 19。4天内体重增加至少2 kg与正确的AHF警报显著相关(P = 0.004),心率超过每分钟110次与错误的AHF警报更显著相关(P = 0.007)。 结论:这项单中心研究强调了远程医疗系统通过检测新发AHF以及室上性心律失常来检测和快速治疗使CHF病程复杂化的心脏失稳的有效性,从而帮助心脏病专家为门诊患者提供更好的随访。
Drugs Aging. 2010-10-1
Telemed J E Health. 2018-12
Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2016-9-17
Eur Heart J. 2023-8-14
Eur Heart J. 2021-9-21
Eur J Heart Fail. 2020-6