Duke University Center for Child and Family Policy, Durham, NC.
UNICEF, New York, NY.
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 2024;45(5):e448-e455. doi: 10.1097/DBP.0000000000001305. Epub 2024 Aug 13.
Forty-three percent of children younger than 5 years in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) are at risk of not meeting their developmental potential. This study investigated how 3 aspects of national development (national life expectancy, education, and income levels) are associated with early childhood development by influencing 5 domains of nurturing care (caregiving, the learning environment, safety and security, nutrition, and the health of the home environment).
In total, 159,959 families with children aged 36 to 59 months living in 51 LMICs provided data. National development was measured using 3 indicators (national life expectancy, education, and income levels), and nurturing care was measured using 10 indicators that collectively captured the 5 nurturing care domains. Path analyses examined how nurturing care indicators mediated the effects of national development on early childhood development.
Higher national life expectancy was directly associated with more advanced childhood development. Higher national levels of education and income were indirectly associated with more advanced childhood development through aspects of nurturing care, such as reduced caregiver psychological aggression or physical violence, increased learning materials and wired appliances in the home environment, and greater caregiver education and child height-for-age. Greater caregiver cognitive caregiving practices promoted childhood development, regardless of levels of national development.
Intervening to promote caregiver education, appropriate discipline strategies, cognitive caregiving practices, and family access to wired appliances, learning materials, and adequate nutrition is key to promoting childhood development in nations with lower levels of national development.
在中低收入国家(LMICs),43%的 5 岁以下儿童面临无法发挥其发展潜力的风险。本研究通过影响 5 个养育关怀领域(照护、学习环境、安全保障、营养以及家庭环境健康),调查了国家发展的 3 个方面(国民预期寿命、教育和收入水平)如何通过影响养育关怀来与幼儿发展相关。
共有来自 51 个 LMICs 的 159959 个 36-59 月龄儿童家庭提供了数据。使用 3 个指标(国民预期寿命、教育和收入水平)衡量国家发展,使用 10 个指标衡量养育关怀,这些指标共同涵盖了 5 个养育关怀领域。路径分析检验了养育关怀指标如何在国家发展对幼儿发展的影响中起中介作用。
国民预期寿命越高,儿童发展越先进。国民教育和收入水平越高,通过养育关怀方面间接与更先进的儿童发展相关,如减少照护者心理攻击或身体暴力、增加家庭学习材料和电器设备、提高照护者教育和儿童身高年龄比。更具认知性的照护者养育实践促进了儿童发展,而不论国家发展水平如何。
促进照护者教育、适当的纪律策略、认知性养育实践以及家庭获得电器设备、学习材料和充足营养,是在国家发展水平较低的国家促进儿童发展的关键。