is Professor and Diagnostic Radiology Residency Program Director, Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic Florida, Jacksonville, Florida, USA.
is a Medical Student, Mercer University School of Medicine, Savannah, Georgia, USA.
J Grad Med Educ. 2024 Aug;16(4):475-478. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-23-00842.1. Epub 2024 Aug 15.
Virtual interviews may limit an applicant's ability to ascertain the culture of a training program. No-stakes campus visits (NSCVs) have been offered but their value is unknown. The purpose of our study was to determine factors that influence applicants' rank lists and determine barriers to and perceptions of NSCVs and their impact on applicants' final rank lists. All interviewed applicants of graduate medical education (GME) programs who agreed to participate in the study were emailed a survey after the 2023 National Resident Matching Program Match. The survey contained sections on demographics, perspectives on factors affecting ranking decisions, and perceptions of NSCVs. Of 796 applicants, 183 (22.9%) who interviewed at 16 different Mayo Clinic GME programs responded to the survey. Of 131 respondents who answered whether they accepted an NSCV offer, 39 (29.8%) accepted. Of 35 respondents who answered whether they thought attending NSCVs impacted their rank, 19 (54.3%) were either uncertain or said yes. Of 34 respondents who answered whether the NSCV influenced their ranking of the program, 16 (47.1%) said their rank did not change, 12 (35.3%) said they ranked the program higher, and 5 (14.7%) said they ranked the program lower. For respondents who did not attend NSCVs, financial burden and lack of time were primary reasons. NSCVs are perceived positively by most respondents. Many either believed they influenced their position on the program's rank list or were unsure. Most respondents said NSCVs either improved or did not change their ranking of the program.
虚拟面试可能会限制申请人了解培训项目文化的能力。已经提供了无风险校园访问(NSCV),但其价值尚不清楚。我们的研究目的是确定影响申请人排名的因素,并确定对 NSCV 的障碍和看法及其对申请人最终排名的影响。在 2023 年全国住院医师匹配计划匹配后,所有参加研究生医学教育(GME)计划面试的申请人都收到了一封电子邮件调查。调查包含了人口统计学、影响排名决策的因素、对 NSCV 的看法等部分。在 796 名申请人中,有 183 名(22.9%)在 16 个不同的梅奥诊所 GME 项目接受了面试,对调查做出了回应。在 131 名回答是否接受 NSCV 邀请的受访者中,有 39 名(29.8%)接受了邀请。在 35 名回答是否认为参加 NSCV 会影响他们的排名的受访者中,有 19 名(54.3%)不确定或说是的。在 34 名回答 NSCV 是否影响他们对项目排名的受访者中,有 16 名(47.1%)表示他们的排名没有变化,12 名(35.3%)表示他们将项目排名提高,5 名(14.7%)表示他们将项目排名降低。对于没有参加 NSCV 的受访者来说,经济负担和缺乏时间是主要原因。大多数受访者对 NSCV 的看法是积极的。许多人要么认为他们影响了他们在项目排名中的位置,要么不确定。大多数受访者表示,NSCV 要么提高了,要么没有改变他们对项目的排名。