Wang Ye, Ai Qing, Shi Taoping, Gao Yu, Jiang Bin, Zhao Wuyi, Jiang Chengjun, Liu Guojun, Zhang Lifeng, Li Huaikang, Gao Fan, Ma Xin, Li Hongzhao, Zhang Xu
Department of Urology, Chinese People's Liberation Army General Hospital, Beijing 100853, China.
Department of Urology, Hainan Hospital of Chinese People's Liberation Army General Hospital, Beijing 100853, China.
Chin Med J (Engl). 2025 Feb 5;138(3):325-331. doi: 10.1097/CM9.0000000000003257. Epub 2024 Aug 16.
Telesurgery has the potential to overcome spatial limitations for surgeons, which depends on surgical robot and the quality of network communication. However, the influence of network latency and bandwidth on telesurgery is not well understood.
A telesurgery system capable of dynamically adjusting image compression ratios in response to bandwidth changes was established between Beijing and Sanya (Hainan province), covering a distance of 3000 km. In total, 108 animal operations, including 12 surgical procedures, were performed. Total latency ranging from 170 ms to 320 ms and bandwidth from 15-20 Mbps to less than 1 Mbps were explored using designed surgical tasks and hemostasis models for renal vein and internal iliac artery rupture bleeding. Network latency, jitter, frame loss, and bit rate code were systemically measured during these operations. National Aeronautics and Space Administration Task Load Index (NASA-TLX) and a self-designed scale measured the workload and subjective perception of surgeons.
All 108 animal telesurgeries, conducted from January 2023 to June 2023, were performed effectively over a total duration of 3866 min. The operations were completed with latency up to 320 ms and bandwidths as low as 1-5 Mbps. Hemostasis for vein and artery rupture bleeding models was effectively achieved under these low bandwidth conditions. The NASA-TLX results indicated that latency significantly impacted surgical performance more than bandwidth and image clarity reductions.
This telesurgery system demonstrated safety and reliability. A total of 320 ms latency is acceptable for telesurgery operations. Reducing image clarity can effectively mitigate the potential latency increase caused by decreased bandwidth, offering a new method to reduce the impact of latency on telesurgery.
远程手术有潜力克服外科医生的空间限制,这取决于手术机器人和网络通信质量。然而,网络延迟和带宽对远程手术的影响尚未得到充分理解。
在北京和三亚(海南省)之间建立了一个能够根据带宽变化动态调整图像压缩比的远程手术系统,距离达3000公里。总共进行了108例动物手术,包括12种手术操作。使用设计的手术任务以及肾静脉和髂内动脉破裂出血的止血模型,探讨了170毫秒至320毫秒的总延迟以及15 - 20兆比特每秒至低于1兆比特每秒的带宽。在这些手术过程中系统地测量了网络延迟、抖动、丢帧和比特率编码。美国国家航空航天局任务负荷指数(NASA - TLX)和自行设计的量表测量了外科医生的工作量和主观感受。
2023年1月至2023年6月进行的所有108例动物远程手术均有效完成,总时长为3866分钟。手术在高达320毫秒的延迟和低至1 - 5兆比特每秒的带宽下完成。在这些低带宽条件下,静脉和动脉破裂出血模型的止血效果良好。NASA - TLX结果表明,延迟对手术性能的影响显著大于带宽和图像清晰度降低的影响。
该远程手术系统显示出安全性和可靠性。远程手术操作中320毫秒的总延迟是可接受的。降低图像清晰度可以有效减轻因带宽降低导致的潜在延迟增加,为减少延迟对远程手术的影响提供了一种新方法。