Li Sheng, Gao Lin, He Song, Yang Dongtai, Wang Chaowei, Zheng Yawen
School of mechanical engineering, Beijing Institute of Technology, Beijing 100081, China.
Laboratory of Integrated Energy System and Renewable Energy, Institute of Engineering Thermophysics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China.
Fundam Res. 2022 Jul 4;4(4):916-925. doi: 10.1016/j.fmre.2022.05.027. eCollection 2024 Jul.
CO capture from coal power plants is an important and necessary solution to realizing carbon neutrality in China, but CCS demonstration deployment in power sector is far behind expectations. Hence, the reduction potential of energy consumption and cost for CCS and its competitiveness to renewable powers are very important to make roadmaps and policies toward carbon neutrality. Unlike the popular recognition that capturing CO from flue gases is technically and commercially mature, this paper notes that it has been proved to be technically feasible but far beyond technology maturity and high energy penalty leads to its immaturity and therefore causes high cost. Additionally, the potential energy penalty reduction of capture is investigated thermodynamically, and future CO avoidance cost is predicted and compared to renewable power (solar PV and onshore wind power). Results show that energy penalty for CO capture can be reduced by 48%-57%. When installation capacity reaches a similar scale to that of solar PV in China (250 GW), CO capture cost in coal power plants can be reduced from the current 28-40 US$/ton to 10-20 US$/ton, and efficiency upgrade contributes to 67%-75% in cost reduction for high coal price conditions. In China, CO capture in coal power plants can be cost competitive with solar PV and onshore wind power. But it is worth noting that the importance and share of CCS role in CO emission reduction is decreasing since renewable power is already well deployed and there is still a lack of large-scale CO capture demonstrations in China. Innovative capture technologies with low energy penalties need to be developed to promote CCS. Results in this work can provide informative references for making roadmaps and policies regarding CO emission reductions that contribute towards carbon neutrality.
从煤电厂捕获二氧化碳是中国实现碳中和的一项重要且必要的解决方案,但电力行业的碳捕集与封存示范部署远远落后于预期。因此,碳捕集与封存的能耗和成本降低潜力及其与可再生能源的竞争力对于制定碳中和路线图和政策非常重要。与普遍认为的从烟气中捕获二氧化碳在技术和商业上已成熟的观点不同,本文指出,虽然已证明其在技术上可行,但远远超出技术成熟度,且高能量惩罚导致其不成熟,进而造成成本高昂。此外,从热力学角度研究了捕获过程中潜在的能量惩罚降低情况,并预测了未来的二氧化碳减排成本,并与可再生能源(太阳能光伏发电和陆上风能发电)进行了比较。结果表明,二氧化碳捕获的能量惩罚可降低48%-57%。当装机容量达到与中国太阳能光伏发电类似规模(250吉瓦)时,煤电厂的二氧化碳捕获成本可从目前的28-40美元/吨降至10-20美元/吨,在高煤价情况下,效率提升对成本降低的贡献为67%-75%。在中国,煤电厂的二氧化碳捕获在成本上可与太阳能光伏发电和陆上风能发电竞争。但值得注意的是,由于可再生能源已得到很好的部署,且中国仍缺乏大规模的二氧化碳捕获示范项目,碳捕集与封存(CCS)在二氧化碳减排中的重要性和所占份额正在下降。需要开发低能量惩罚的创新捕获技术以推动碳捕集与封存。本研究结果可为制定有助于实现碳中和的二氧化碳减排路线图和政策提供参考信息。